search

espressif / esp-lwip

Fork of lwIP (https://savannah.nongnu.org/projects/lwip/) with ESP-IDF specific patches
Other
85 stars 129 forks source link

Disabling IPV4 causes compilation errors (IDFGH-12116) #64

Closed ShubhadaHarkut-eaton closed 5 months ago

ShubhadaHarkut-eaton commented 7 months ago

Disabling IVP4 and building the idf ethernet example code only with IPV6 support enabled leading to many compilation error idf version used : 4.4 os : windows ESP : ESP32-WROVER-B

disabling LWIP_IPV4 in opts.h and enabling LWIP_IPV6 in the same file along with other menuconfig configurations for rnabling IPV6

espressif-abhikroy commented 7 months ago

Hi @ShubhadaHarkut-eaton, The option to disable IPv4 is not available for IDF release v4.4 and v5.0. It's available from IDF release v5.1 onwards.

ShubhadaHarkut-eaton commented 7 months ago

Hi @espressif-abhikroy Any idea if any one has tried esp32 with ipv6 configuration as wireguard client ?

espressif-abhikroy commented 7 months ago

Sorry, I am not aware of such usage.

sgryphon commented 6 months ago

I am not sure if it is relevant for your scenario, but I recently put up a pull request to update the protocol examples to work with all/any network configuration. The branch is here: https://github.com/espressif/esp-idf/pull/13250

The update examples work out of the box (no config or code changes) with all network types: IPv4-only, IPv6-only, and dual stack. (You do need to provide config for things like your WiFi password)

Note that this is not the same as turning off IPv4 -- IPv4 is still turned on, just not used. The updated example works in an IPv6-only network, if that is your objective. See the example outputs for IPv6-only network. If you have DNS64/NAT64 available, then it can even connect from an IPv6-only network to an IPv4-only server.

However, IPv4 is still actually on.

If you know IPv4 is not necessary, e.g. if you are developing a Matter device where only IPv6 is required, and want to reduce memory size and development/testing effort, then you could also turn off IPv4 completely. I also tested this scenario (current LWIP/IDF) and found a small compilation bug in the PPP code used in the examples -- this is also fixed in my PR branch, i.e. it does compile with IPv4 turn off (although there is no need to, as the examples works fine in an IPv6-only network without config changes).

david-cermak commented 5 months ago

Closing as won't do, as IPv4-only is supported from v5.1