ETVComskip-2.0-10.6 does not automatically mark commercials when recording is completed

What steps will reproduce the problem?
1. install ETVComskip-2.0-10.6
2. have shows record in EyeTV 3.4

What is the expected output? What do you see instead?

When completed, commercials are not marked. Running the /Library/Application\ 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/MacOS/MarkCommercials
command by hand afterwards does mark them.

Error log shows:

Wed May 26 12:27:01 2010 -  1. Processing "ABC 6 News at Noon" on [WSYX] 
channel [9]...
Wed May 26 12:27:01 2010 - Path to recording is /Users/dreed/Movies/EyeTV 
Archive/ABC 6 
News at Noon.eyetvsched/0000000011ad834b.eyetvr
Wed May 26 12:27:01 2010 - Changing directory to /Users/dreed/Movies/EyeTV 
Archive/ABC 6 
News at Noon.eyetvsched
Wed May 26 12:27:01 2010 - Running: "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/wine" "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.exe" --ini="/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" "0000000011ad834b.mpg" > 
/Users/dreed/Library/Logs/ETVComskip/296584011_comskip.log 2>&1
Wed May 26 12:29:59 2010 - Return code is: 26368, 0x6700
Wed May 26 12:29:59 2010 - Error code is: 103, 0x67
Wed May 26 12:29:59 2010 - Error: unknown error code from comskip: 103, 
assuming it 
worked.
Wed May 26 12:29:59 2010 - Error: accessing 0000000011ad834b.edl
(2, 'No such file or directory')

What version of the product are you using? On what operating system?
ETVComskip-2.0 on 10.6.3

Please provide any additional information below.

Original issue reported on code.google.com by dave2...@gmail.com on 26 May 2010 at 4:59

What version of EyeTV and what hardware are you running.  The included version 
of
comskip only works with mpeg-2 recordings, and some hardware produces mpeg4.

The donation-ware version of comskip.exe may work for mpeg4 recordings.
What's in /Users/dreed/Library/Logs/ETVComskip/296584011_comskip.log?

-Jon

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 26 May 2010 at 5:04

EyeTV 3.4, EyeTV 250 Plus

The file I recorded was a Clear QAM HD local channel and it does work when 
running the 
/Library/Application\ 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/MacOS/MarkCommercials

command by hand so I don't think it's an unsupported MPEG file.

Here's the log file:

Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
Comskip 0.80.031, made using:
mpeg2dec-0.4.0 - by Michel Lespinasse <walken@zoy.org> and Aaron Holtzman
 0:39:01 - 532 frames in 1.00 sec (532.00 fps), 1.00 sec (532.00 fps), 94%
 0:39:02 - 558 frames in 2.05 sec (272.20 fps), 1.05 sec (24.76 fps), 89%
 0:39:02 - 615 frames in 3.19 sec (192.79 fps), 1.14 sec (50.00 fps), 89%
 0:39:05 - 740 frames in 4.50 sec (164.44 fps), 1.30 sec (96.15 fps), 91%
 0:39:06 - 811 frames in 5.65 sec (143.54 fps), 1.15 sec (61.74 fps), 92%
 0:39:07 - 870 frames in 6.78 sec (128.32 fps), 1.13 sec (52.21 fps), 92%
 0:39:08 - 936 frames in 7.91 sec (118.33 fps), 1.12 sec (58.93 fps), 93%
 0:39:09 - 990 frames in 9.01 sec (109.88 fps), 1.10 sec (49.09 fps), 92%
 0:39:10 - 1065 frames in 10.18 sec (104.62 fps), 1.17 sec (64.10 fps), 94%
 0:39:11 - 1122 frames in 11.29 sec (99.38 fps), 1.10 sec (51.82 fps), 93%
 0:39:12 - 1188 frames in 12.42 sec (95.65 fps), 1.13 sec (58.41 fps), 94%
 0:39:13 - 1245 frames in 13.54 sec (91.95 fps), 1.11 sec (51.35 fps), 94%
 0:39:14 - 1305 frames in 14.66 sec (89.02 fps), 1.12 sec (53.57 fps), 94%
 0:39:15 - 1373 frames in 15.80 sec (86.90 fps), 1.14 sec (59.65 fps), 95%
 0:39:17 - 1500 frames in 17.03 sec (88.08 fps), 1.24 sec (102.42 fps), 95%
 0:39:19 - 1569 frames in 18.21 sec (86.16 fps), 1.17 sec (58.97 fps), 96%
 0:39:19 - 1626 frames in 19.35 sec (84.03 fps), 1.14 sec (50.00 fps), 95%
 0:39:21 - 1696 frames in 20.51 sec (82.69 fps), 1.15 sec (60.87 fps), 96%
 0:39:22 - 1750 frames in 21.64 sec (80.87 fps), 1.13 sec (47.79 fps), 96%
 0:39:23 - 1809 frames in 22.77 sec (79.45 fps), 1.13 sec (52.21 fps), 95%
 0:39:24 - 1881 frames in 23.91 sec (78.67 fps), 1.14 sec (63.16 fps), 96%
 0:39:25 - 1935 frames in 25.01 sec (77.37 fps), 1.10 sec (49.09 fps), 96%
 0:39:26 - 2004 frames in 26.15 sec (76.63 fps), 1.14 sec (60.53 fps), 96%
 0:39:27 - 2061 frames in 27.28 sec (75.55 fps), 1.12 sec (50.89 fps), 96%
 0:39:28 - 2133 frames in 28.44 sec (75.00 fps), 1.16 sec (62.07 fps), 96%
 0:39:30 - 2257 frames in 29.69 sec (76.02 fps), 1.25 sec (99.20 fps), 96%
 0:39:31 - 2313 frames in 30.81 sec (75.07 fps), 1.11 sec (50.45 fps), 96%
 0:39:32 - 2383 frames in 31.96 sec (74.56 fps), 1.14 sec (61.40 fps), 97%
 0:39:33 - 2451 frames in 33.09 sec (74.07 fps), 1.13 sec (60.18 fps), 97%
 0:39:34 - 2508 frames in 34.23 sec (73.27 fps), 1.14 sec (50.00 fps), 97%
 0:39:35 - 2568 frames in 35.37 sec (72.60 fps), 1.13 sec (53.10 fps), 98%
 0:39:36 - 2606 frames in 36.47 sec (71.46 fps), 1.10 sec (34.55 fps), 97%
 0:39:37 - 2691 frames in 37.60 sec (71.57 fps), 1.12 sec (75.89 fps), 97%
 0:39:38 - 2765 frames in 38.73 sec (71.39 fps), 1.12 sec (66.07 fps), 97%
 0:39:39 - 2817 frames in 39.82 sec (70.74 fps), 1.09 sec (47.71 fps), 97%
 0:39:41 - 2886 frames in 40.93 sec (70.51 fps), 1.11 sec (62.16 fps), 97%
 0:39:43 - 3012 frames in 42.21 sec (71.36 fps), 1.29 sec (97.67 fps), 97%
 0:39:44 - 3072 frames in 43.36 sec (70.85 fps), 1.14 sec (52.63 fps), 97%
 0:39:45 - 3141 frames in 44.51 sec (70.57 fps), 1.14 sec (60.53 fps), 97%
 0:39:46 - 3196 frames in 45.65 sec (70.01 fps), 1.14 sec (48.25 fps), 97%
 0:39:47 - 3267 frames in 46.81 sec (69.79 fps), 1.15 sec (61.74 fps), 98%
 0:39:48 - 3324 frames in 47.94 sec (69.34 fps), 1.13 sec (50.44 fps), 97%
 0:39:49 - 3390 frames in 49.10 sec (69.04 fps), 1.17 sec (56.41 fps), 97%
 0:39:50 - 3461 frames in 50.29 sec (68.82 fps), 1.18 sec (60.17 fps), 98%
 0:39:51 - 3517 frames in 51.43 sec (68.38 fps), 1.14 sec (49.12 fps), 98%
 0:39:52 - 3587 frames in 52.60 sec (68.19 fps), 1.17 sec (59.83 fps), 98%
 0:39:54 - 3700 frames in 53.92 sec (68.62 fps), 1.31 sec (86.26 fps), 97%
 0:39:55 - 3770 frames in 55.08 sec (68.45 fps), 1.16 sec (60.34 fps), 98%
 0:39:56 - 3839 frames in 56.28 sec (68.21 fps), 1.20 sec (57.50 fps), 98%
 0:39:57 - 3896 frames in 57.43 sec (67.84 fps), 1.14 sec (50.00 fps), 98%
 0:39:58 - 3965 frames in 58.60 sec (67.66 fps), 1.17 sec (58.97 fps), 98%
 0:39:59 - 4022 frames in 59.74 sec (67.33 fps), 1.14 sec (50.00 fps), 98%
 0:40:00 - 4077 frames in 60.88 sec (66.97 fps), 1.13 sec (48.67 fps), 98%
 0:40:01 - 4150 frames in 62.04 sec (66.89 fps), 1.17 sec (62.39 fps), 98%
 0:40:04 - 4276 frames in 63.39 sec (67.46 fps), 1.34 sec (94.03 fps), 98%
 0:40:05 - 4332 frames in 64.54 sec (67.12 fps), 1.15 sec (48.70 fps), 98%
 0:40:06 - 4400 frames in 65.70 sec (66.97 fps), 1.16 sec (58.62 fps), 98%
 0:40:07 - 4456 frames in 66.84 sec (66.67 fps), 1.13 sec (49.56 fps), 98%
 0:40:08 - 4527 frames in 68.00 sec (66.57 fps), 1.16 sec (61.21 fps), 98%
 0:40:09 - 4583 frames in 69.13 sec (66.30 fps), 1.13 sec (49.56 fps), 98%
 0:40:10 - 4653 frames in 70.31 sec (66.18 fps), 1.18 sec (59.32 fps), 98%
 0:40:11 - 4710 frames in 71.47 sec (65.90 fps), 1.15 sec (49.57 fps), 98%
 0:40:13 - 4834 frames in 72.76 sec (66.44 fps), 1.29 sec (96.12 fps), 98%
 0:40:14 - 4906 frames in 73.96 sec (66.33 fps), 1.20 sec (60.00 fps), 98%
 0:40:15 - 4961 frames in 75.08 sec (66.08 fps), 1.13 sec (48.67 fps), 98%
 0:40:16 - 5030 frames in 76.26 sec (65.96 fps), 1.18 sec (58.47 fps), 98%
 0:40:17 - 5086 frames in 77.40 sec (65.71 fps), 1.13 sec (49.56 fps), 98%
 0:40:18 - 5158 frames in 78.57 sec (65.65 fps), 1.17 sec (61.54 fps), 98%
 0:40:19 - 5212 frames in 79.69 sec (65.40 fps), 1.12 sec (48.21 fps), 98%
 0:40:20 - 5281 frames in 80.85 sec (65.32 fps), 1.16 sec (59.48 fps), 98%
 0:40:21 - 5339 frames in 81.98 sec (65.13 fps), 1.12 sec (51.79 fps), 98%
 0:40:23 - 5465 frames in 83.27 sec (65.63 fps), 1.30 sec (96.92 fps), 98%
 0:40:25 - 5536 frames in 84.43 sec (65.57 fps), 1.15 sec (61.74 fps), 98%
 0:40:25 - 5595 frames in 85.57 sec (65.39 fps), 1.13 sec (52.21 fps), 98%
 0:40:27 - 5664 frames in 86.73 sec (65.31 fps), 1.15 sec (60.00 fps), 98%
 0:40:28 - 5719 frames in 87.85 sec (65.10 fps), 1.12 sec (49.11 fps), 98%
 0:40:29 - 5791 frames in 89.03 sec (65.05 fps), 1.18 sec (61.02 fps), 98%
 0:40:30 - 5848 frames in 90.19 sec (64.84 fps), 1.15 sec (49.57 fps), 98%
 0:40:31 - 5917 frames in 91.36 sec (64.77 fps), 1.16 sec (59.48 fps), 98%
 0:40:32 - 5972 frames in 92.49 sec (64.57 fps), 1.12 sec (49.11 fps), 98%
 0:40:34 - 6100 frames in 93.79 sec (65.04 fps), 1.30 sec (98.46 fps), 98%
 0:40:35 - 6169 frames in 94.93 sec (64.98 fps), 1.14 sec (60.53 fps), 98%
 0:40:36 - 6223 frames in 96.04 sec (64.80 fps), 1.11 sec (48.65 fps), 98%
 0:40:37 - 6295 frames in 97.19 sec (64.77 fps), 1.15 sec (62.61 fps), 99%
 0:40:38 - 6352 frames in 98.31 sec (64.61 fps), 1.12 sec (50.89 fps), 98%
 0:40:39 - 6421 frames in 99.46 sec (64.56 fps), 1.14 sec (60.53 fps), 99%
 0:40:40 - 6475 frames in 100.58 sec (64.38 fps), 1.12 sec (48.21 fps), 98%
 0:40:41 - 6544 frames in 101.73 sec (64.33 fps), 1.14 sec (60.53 fps), 98%
 0:40:42 - 6598 frames in 102.85 sec (64.15 fps), 1.12 sec (48.21 fps), 98%
 0:40:43 - 6667 frames in 104.01 sec (64.10 fps), 1.16 sec (59.48 fps), 98%
 0:40:44 - 6724 frames in 105.15 sec (63.95 fps), 1.14 sec (50.00 fps), 98%
 0:40:46 - 6850 frames in 106.51 sec (64.31 fps), 1.36 sec (92.65 fps), 98%
 0:40:48 - 6920 frames in 107.68 sec (64.26 fps), 1.16 sec (60.34 fps), 99%
 0:40:49 - 6976 frames in 108.82 sec (64.11 fps), 1.14 sec (49.12 fps), 98%
 0:40:50 - 7045 frames in 109.99 sec (64.05 fps), 1.17 sec (58.97 fps), 99%
 0:40:51 - 7116 frames in 111.15 sec (64.02 fps), 1.16 sec (61.21 fps), 99%
 0:40:52 - 7172 frames in 112.29 sec (63.87 fps), 1.14 sec (49.12 fps), 99%
 0:40:53 - 7230 frames in 113.43 sec (63.74 fps), 1.13 sec (51.33 fps), 98%
 0:40:54 - 7302 frames in 114.59 sec (63.72 fps), 1.16 sec (62.07 fps), 99%
 0:40:56 - 7430 frames in 115.88 sec (64.12 fps), 1.28 sec (100.00 fps), 99%
 0:40:57 - 7486 frames in 117.01 sec (63.98 fps), 1.13 sec (49.56 fps), 99%
 0:40:58 - 7556 frames in 118.22 sec (63.91 fps), 1.21 sec (57.85 fps), 99%
 0:40:59 - 7610 frames in 119.33 sec (63.77 fps), 1.10 sec (49.09 fps), 99%
 0:41:00 - 7679 frames in 120.51 sec (63.72 fps), 1.17 sec (58.97 fps), 99%
 0:41:01 - 7739 frames in 121.61 sec (63.64 fps), 1.10 sec (54.55 fps), 99%
 0:41:02 - 7796 frames in 122.70 sec (63.54 fps), 1.08 sec (52.78 fps), 99%
 0:41:04 - 7865 frames in 123.83 sec (63.51 fps), 1.12 sec (61.61 fps), 99%
 0:41:05 - 7925 frames in 124.94 sec (63.43 fps), 1.11 sec (54.05 fps), 99%
 0:41:06 - 7997 frames in 126.07 sec (63.43 fps), 1.14 sec (63.16 fps), 99%
 0:41:06 - 8051 frames in 127.19 sec (63.30 fps), 1.11 sec (48.65 fps), 99%
 0:41:09 - 8180 frames in 128.40 sec (63.71 fps), 1.20 sec (107.50 fps), 99%
 0:41:10 - 8249 frames in 129.54 sec (63.68 fps), 1.14 sec (60.53 fps), 99%
 0:41:11 - 8309 frames in 130.66 sec (63.59 fps), 1.11 sec (54.05 fps), 99%
 0:41:12 - 8366 frames in 131.77 sec (63.49 fps), 1.11 sec (51.35 fps), 99%
 0:41:13 - 8432 frames in 132.91 sec (63.44 fps), 1.13 sec (58.41 fps), 99%
 0:41:14 - 8501 frames in 134.07 sec (63.41 fps), 1.16 sec (59.48 fps), 99%
 0:41:15 - 8555 frames in 135.17 sec (63.29 fps), 1.10 sec (49.09 fps), 99%
 0:41:16 - 8624 frames in 136.34 sec (63.25 fps), 1.16 sec (59.48 fps), 99%
 0:41:17 - 8680 frames in 137.45 sec (63.15 fps), 1.11 sec (50.45 fps), 99%
 0:41:18 - 8750 frames in 138.59 sec (63.14 fps), 1.13 sec (61.95 fps), 99%
 0:41:19 - 8805 frames in 139.70 sec (63.03 fps), 1.11 sec (49.55 fps), 99%
 0:41:20 - 8879 frames in 140.81 sec (63.06 fps), 1.11 sec (66.67 fps), 99%
 0:41:21 - 8937 frames in 141.90 sec (62.98 fps), 1.09 sec (53.21 fps), 99%
 0:41:23 - 9062 frames in 143.15 sec (63.30 fps), 1.25 sec (100.00 fps), 99%
 0:41:25 - 9131 frames in 144.30 sec (63.28 fps), 1.15 sec (60.00 fps), 99%
 0:41:26 - 9185 frames in 145.42 sec (63.16 fps), 1.12 sec (48.21 fps), 99%
 0:41:27 - 9254 frames in 146.56 sec (63.14 fps), 1.13 sec (61.06 fps), 99%
 0:41:28 - 9308 frames in 147.67 sec (63.03 fps), 1.11 sec (48.65 fps), 99%
 0:41:29 - 9380 frames in 148.80 sec (63.04 fps), 1.13 sec (63.72 fps), 99%
 0:41:30 - 9438 frames in 149.91 sec (62.96 fps), 1.10 sec (52.73 fps), 99%
 0:41:31 - 9497 frames in 151.00 sec (62.89 fps), 1.09 sec (54.13 fps), 99%
 0:41:32 - 9567 frames in 152.13 sec (62.89 fps), 1.13 sec (61.95 fps), 99%
 0:41:33 - 9623 frames in 153.23 sec (62.80 fps), 1.10 sec (50.91 fps), 99%
 0:41:34 - 9692 frames in 154.36 sec (62.79 fps), 1.13 sec (61.06 fps), 99%
 0:41:35 - 9761 frames in 155.51 sec (62.77 fps), 1.14 sec (60.53 fps), 99%
 0:41:36 - 9815 frames in 156.64 sec (62.66 fps), 1.13 sec (47.79 fps), 99%
 0:41:38 - 9944 frames in 157.95 sec (62.96 fps), 1.31 sec (98.47 fps), 99%
 0:41:39 - 10001 frames in 159.06 sec (62.88 fps), 1.11 sec (51.35 fps), 99%
 0:41:40 - 10072 frames in 160.22 sec (62.86 fps), 1.16 sec (61.21 fps), 99%
 0:41:41 - 10129 frames in 161.35 sec (62.78 fps), 1.12 sec (50.89 fps), 99%
 0:41:42 - 10198 frames in 162.52 sec (62.75 fps), 1.17 sec (58.97 fps), 99%
 0:41:43 - 10254 frames in 163.68 sec (62.65 fps), 1.16 sec (48.28 fps), 99%
 0:41:44 - 10325 frames in 164.84 sec (62.64 fps), 1.15 sec (61.74 fps), 99%
 0:41:45 - 10382 frames in 165.97 sec (62.55 fps), 1.12 sec (50.89 fps), 99%
 0:41:46 - 10452 frames in 167.15 sec (62.53 fps), 1.19 sec (58.82 fps), 99%
 0:41:49 - 10578 frames in 168.43 sec (62.80 fps), 1.28 sec (98.44 fps), 99%
 0:41:50 - 10634 frames in 169.56 sec (62.72 fps), 1.12 sec (50.00 fps), 99%
 0:41:51 - 10704 frames in 170.70 sec (62.71 fps), 1.14 sec (61.40 fps), 99%
 0:41:52 - 10760 frames in 171.83 sec (62.62 fps), 1.12 sec (50.00 fps), 99%
 0:41:53 - 10831 frames in 172.95 sec (62.63 fps), 1.12 sec (63.39 fps), 99%
 0:41:55 - 10929 frames in 177.13 sec (61.70 fps), 4.18 sec (23.44 fps), 99%

10939 frames decoded in 177.17 seconds (61.74 fps)
The commandline used was:
"Z:\Library\Application Support\ETVComskip\comskip\comskip.exe" 
"--ini=/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" 0000000011ad834b.mpg

Opening 0000000011ad834b.mpg
Setting ini file to /Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini 
as per commandline
Using /Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini for 
initiation values.

Original comment by dave2...@gmail.com on 26 May 2010 at 5:17

That's odd.

The relevant part of the error log is:

Wed May 26 12:29:59 2010 - Error: accessing 0000000011ad834b.edl (2, 'No such 
file or
directory')

Which means that the file comskip.exe should have produced (which contains the 
edit
points) didn't get written or couldn't be found.  Now that you've run 
MarkCommercials
manually, the file will likely be there so we can't check the .eyetvr directory
directly to see what happened.

Next time this happens, look in the corresponding .eyetvr directory and see 
what's
there.  If there's not an .edl file, then something weird happened in 
comskip.exe,
and if there is then the problem would seem to be in MarkCommercials.py.

-Jon

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 26 May 2010 at 5:42

Where should the .edl file be?

I just told it to record some show that was on and here's what's in the 
directory for the show when it's done. I 
don't see a .edl file and the .eyetvr file is not a directory.

507 iMac:~/Movies/EyeTV Archive/Judge Joe Brown.eyetv $ ls -l
total 7155944
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed      306560 May 26 14:32 0000000011ad993f.eyetvi
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed        3412 May 26 14:32 0000000011ad993f.eyetvp
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed        2244 May 26 14:32 0000000011ad993f.eyetvr
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed       54440 May 26 14:31 0000000011ad993f.log
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed        8890 May 26 14:01 0000000011ad993f.logo.txt
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed  3660664184 May 26 14:32 0000000011ad993f.mpg
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed      159802 May 26 14:01 
0000000011ad993f.thumbnail.tiff
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed     2628626 May 26 14:01 0000000011ad993f.tiff
-rw-r--r--  1 dreed  dreed           0 May 26 14:00 0000000011ad993f.txt

Original comment by dave2...@gmail.com on 26 May 2010 at 6:47

I'm pretty sure the .edl file should have been in that directory.
I *think* the .log, and .logo.txt files there are produced by comskip too, so I
don't get why you don't have an .edl file.

Anything interesting in that .log file?

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 26 May 2010 at 7:06

Yes, the .log and .logo.txt are definitely created by comskip. I don't see 
anything in them about the edl file.

Could it be that the directory is .eyetvsched while the file is recording and 
then when it's done, the name of 
the directory is .eyetv ?

I had just tried the ETVComSkip-1.0.3 after seeing the TUAW blog post and it 
seemed to work fine and then 
downloaded the 2.0 version this morning and it doesn't. I did run the uninstall 
script for the 1.0.3 version 
before installing the 2.0 version.

Original comment by dave2...@gmail.com on 26 May 2010 at 7:26

I noticed one thing and I am starting to wonder whether it could be related.
I saw that the new v2 installs Wine.
I manually launched Wine and got the typical warning telling me it had be 
downloaded off the Internet, 
blahblahblah, do I want to allow it.

I *suspect* that it might explain why the process fails to launch comskip.exe. 
Wine cannot actually load it 
until Wine is allowed to run on the Mac.

I haven't yet tested whether manually launching it once and allowing it to run 
corrects the issue (I'm having 
other EyeTV-related issues).

On a side note… I already have CrossOver on my Mac. Do I really need Wine and 
is there a way to have 
EyeTVComskip run through CrossOver instead?

Side-note #2: the Wine build on the .dmg is not the latest. Wine immediately 
offered me to download v 
1.1.44.

Original comment by korventeen on 27 May 2010 at 1:42

Well I made more tests…
For some reason, it looks like something (and I can't definitively link it to 
EyeTVComskip — yet), is making my 
external drive eject.
My recordings are set to be on this external drive.

Here is the log I got this time:

Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - /Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.py, 
0.4.0 starting
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Command line: ['/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.py', 
'--log', 
'296623130']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Application name: EyeTV
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Cfg files read: ['/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.cfg', 
'/Volumes/GrisGris/Users/corentin/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.cfg']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - List Delimiter: |
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Excluded Channels: ['500', '501', '502', '503', 
'504', '505', '506', '507', '508', 
'509', '525', '526', '527', '528', '529', '530', '531', '600', '601', '602', 
'603', '604', '605', '606', '625', '626', '627', 
'630', '700', '701', '702', '703', '725', '726', '727', '728', '729', '730']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Excluded Titles: ['']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Excluded Station names: ['']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Checking communications to EyeTV with 3 retries
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 -   Attempt 1 worked
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Getting recordings
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Recordings: 
[app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-
Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(294631080), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & 
Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(295837080), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-
Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(292903080), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & 
Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(293508927), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-
Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296013480), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & 
Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(289961946), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-
Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296623130), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & 
Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296623131)]
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Found recording 296623130
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Marker count: 0
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 -  1. Processing "Two and a Half Men" on [WWJ HDTV] 
channel [233]...
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Path to recording is /Volumes/Whopper/EyeTV 
Archive/Two and a Half Men - 
26 mai 2010 23_18.eyetv/0000000011ae1c1a.eyetvr
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Changing directory to /Volumes/Whopper/EyeTV 
Archive/Two and a Half Men - 
26 mai 2010 23_18.eyetv
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Running: "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/wine" "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.exe" --ini="/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" "0000000011ae1c1a.mpg" > 
/Volumes/GrisGris/Users/corentin/Library/Logs/ETVComskip/296623130_comskip.log 
2>&1
Wed May 26 23:19:48 2010 - Return code is: 26368, 0x6700
Wed May 26 23:19:48 2010 - Error code is: 103, 0x67
Wed May 26 23:19:48 2010 - Error: unknown error code from comskip: 103, 
assuming it worked.
Wed May 26 23:19:48 2010 - Error: accessing 0000000011ae1c1a.edl
(2, 'No such file or directory')

Original comment by korventeen on 27 May 2010 at 3:32

> On a side note… I already have CrossOver on my Mac. Do I really need Wine 
> and is there a way to have EyeTVComskip run through CrossOver instead?

Possibly you could use CrossOver, but I don't know.  How you would do it would
be to modify MarkCommercials.py in

/Library/Application
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.py

and replace the call to wine with however you invoke CrossOver to run an 
application.

>  Side-note #2: the Wine build on the .dmg is not the latest. Wine immediately
offered me to download v 1.1.44. 

If I recall correctly, I tried the update and it hosed my wine install and it 
didn't
run comskip.exe any more.  I'd avoid it if I were you.

> I *suspect* that it might explain why the process fails to launch 
comskip.exe. 
> Wine cannot actually load it until Wine is allowed to run on the Mac.

Excellent theory, but one that I can't test b/c I've already authorized wine to 
run
on my machine.

Did it work for you subsequently?

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 27 May 2010 at 4:45

 korventeen, 

What is in the file

/Volumes/GrisGris/Users/corentin/Library/Logs/ETVComskip/296623130_comskip.log?

What happens if you run 

/Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/wine"
"/Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.exe"
--ini="/Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini"
"0000000011ae1c1a.mpg"

(all on one line) manually?

-Jon

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 27 May 2010 at 4:50

As for the command, there has to be a problem with it. I get nothing:
Corentin-MBP:~ corentin$ /Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/wine" "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.exe" --ini="/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" "0000000011ae1c1a.mpg"
> 

It looks like it's waiting for an input.

Here is the log you asked for:
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - /Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.py, 
0.4.0 starting
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Command line: ['/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.py', 
'--log', 
'296623130']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Application name: EyeTV
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Cfg files read: ['/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.cfg', 
'/Volumes/GrisGris/Users/corentin/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.cfg']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - List Delimiter: |
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Excluded Channels: ['500', '501', '502', '503', 
'504', '505', '506', '507', '508', 
'509', '525', '526', '527', '528', '529', '530', '531', '600', '601', '602', 
'603', '604', '605', '606', '625', '626', '627', 
'630', '700', '701', '702', '703', '725', '726', '727', '728', '729', '730']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Excluded Titles: ['']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Excluded Station names: ['']
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Checking communications to EyeTV with 3 retries
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 -   Attempt 1 worked
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Getting recordings
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Recordings: 
[app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-
Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(294631080), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & 
Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(295837080), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-
Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(292903080), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & 
Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(293508927), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-
Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296013480), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & 
Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(289961946), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-
Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296623130), 
app(u'/Volumes/GrisGris/Applications/Images-Dessins/Video/Encodeurs & 
Utilitaires/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296623131)]
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Found recording 296623130
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Marker count: 0
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 -  1. Processing "Two and a Half Men" on [WWJ HDTV] 
channel [233]...
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Path to recording is /Volumes/Whopper/EyeTV 
Archive/Two and a Half Men - 
26 mai 2010 23_18.eyetv/0000000011ae1c1a.eyetvr
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Changing directory to /Volumes/Whopper/EyeTV 
Archive/Two and a Half Men - 
26 mai 2010 23_18.eyetv
Wed May 26 23:19:01 2010 - Running: "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/wine" "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.exe" --ini="/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" "0000000011ae1c1a.mpg" > 
/Volumes/GrisGris/Users/corentin/Library/Logs/ETVComskip/296623130_comskip.log 
2>&1
Wed May 26 23:19:48 2010 - Return code is: 26368, 0x6700
Wed May 26 23:19:48 2010 - Error code is: 103, 0x67
Wed May 26 23:19:48 2010 - Error: unknown error code from comskip: 103, 
assuming it worked.
Wed May 26 23:19:48 2010 - Error: accessing 0000000011ae1c1a.edl
(2, 'No such file or directory')

Original comment by korventeen on 27 May 2010 at 11:36

Someone pointed out that the versions of comskip.ini in the 10.5 and 10.6
distributions are different.  I think that might be the key datum.

Could someone with 10.6 try editing their comskip.ini file 

/Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini

and replacing

live_tv=0 with live_tv=1

and live_tv_retries=4 with live_tv_retries=16.

I wouldn't be surprised at all if that doesn't fix the problem.

-Jon

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 31 May 2010 at 5:44

Jon,

Thanks! That seemed to fix it. I just recorded a 30 minute show and here's the 
end of the log file. It still seems 
to indicate some errors, but it did mark the commercials.

Mon May 31 09:28:11 2010 - Running: "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/wine" "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.exe" --ini="/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" "0000000011b3f0e0.mpg" > 
/Users/dreed/Library/Logs/ETVComskip/297005280_comskip.log 2>&1
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Return code is: 26368, 0x6700
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Error code is: 103, 0x67
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Error: unknown error code from comskip: 103, 
assuming it worked.
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Plist file contents: ['570.74\t763.96\t0\n', 
'1150.22\t1301.10\t0\n', 
'1618.08\t1784.28\t0\n', '1912.51\t1942.67\t0\n']
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Processing plist file line: '570.74  763.96  0
'
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Adding marker, start: 570, end: 763
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Processing plist file line: '1150.22 1301.10 0
'
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Adding marker, start: 1150, end: 1301
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Processing plist file line: '1618.08 1784.28 0
'
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Adding marker, start: 1618, end: 1784
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Processing plist file line: '1912.51 1942.67 0
'
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Adding marker, start: 1912, end: 1942
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Setting markers on recording
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Adding marker: [{'position': 570.74000000000001, 
aem.AEType('leng'): 
193.22000000000003}, {'position': 1150.22, aem.AEType('leng'): 
150.87999999999988}, {'position': 
1618.0799999999999, aem.AEType('leng'): 166.20000000000005}, {'position': 
1912.51, aem.AEType('leng'): 
30.160000000000082}]
Mon May 31 10:02:16 2010 - Exiting

Original comment by dave2...@gmail.com on 31 May 2010 at 2:07

So I have played around with this and have concluded that the edl file error is 
due to the file directory 
changing from .eyetvsched to .eyetv before the edl file is written.  As posted 
by jon.christopher, the solution 
to this problem is to write the edl file as the video is being processed by 
changing the live_tv flag in the 
comskip.ini file.

/Library/Application Support/EYVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini
Change live_tv=0 to live_tv=1
and live_tv_retries=4 to live_tv_retries=16

Now dave2048 posted that he made this change and that it fixed the problem for 
him, but still reported an 
error.  My guess is that this error is also due to the directory change.  I am 
guessing that comskip.exe is 
processing the video, and then the file pointer is suddenly broken because the 
file path has changed and as a 
result an error happens.  I don't know how to test or fix this one.  Maybe 
someone else has an idea.

There are two solutions to making eyetv-comskip work with Mac OS X 10.6.3 and 
EyeTV 3.4.
1) Change the comskip.ini file as stated above
or
2) Remove the RecordingStarted.scpt and change the RecordingDone.scpt so that 
the commercials are not 
marked until after the video is done recording.

Original comment by troy.gro...@gmail.com on 31 May 2010 at 8:18

I managed to also make some tests (despite my other EyeTV ^#%$^%Q$ problems) 
and I can confirm too that 
after modifying the comskip.ini file, the commercials were properly marked in 
the file.

Corentin

Original comment by korventeen on 31 May 2010 at 9:20

2.0.1 includes the correct comskip.ini which should fix this issue.

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 1 Jun 2010 at 1:48

Changed state: Fixed

ETVComskip-2.0.2-10.6.dmg doesn't install files into /Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip. Installer says it 
installed OK. ETVComskip does not automatically mark commercials when recording 
is completed. I'm using 
EyeTV 3.4

Original comment by masonryd...@gmail.com on 2 Jun 2010 at 5:32

I am seeing the same issue as well, I have Mac OS X 10.6.4, EyeTV 3.4 and the 
latest build of comskip and none of my commercials are being marked.

Original comment by disjauk...@gmail.com on 1 Jul 2010 at 12:21

@disjaukifa: Did you install version 2.0.2?? It fixed the issue from me.
Also, I’d suggest you launch Wine from /Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip manually at least once to make sure the Security dialog (You 
are launching Wine for the first time, blahblahblah) won’t be an issue 
anymore later.

Original comment by korventeen on 1 Jul 2010 at 2:00

I launched wine and updated to ver 2.2 but etv-comskip still crashed.  I was 
getting an error about not having freetype.  I'm not sure how to install a 
windows program on a mac machine running 10.6.4.
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
fixme:xrender:XRender_AlphaBlend Unable to AlphaBlend without Xrender
fixme:menubuilder:SaveIconResAsXPM Unsupported color depth 32-bit
err:module:load_builtin_dll failed to load .so lib for builtin L"winemp3.acm": 
dlopen(/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/../lib/wine/winemp3.acm.so, 
2): Library not loaded: /Users/mike/Documents/darwine/usr/lib/libmpg123.0.dylib
  Referenced from: /Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/
err:module:load_builtin_dll failed to load .so lib for builtin L"winemp3.acm": 
dlopen(/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/../lib/wine/winemp3.acm.so, 
2): Library not loaded: /Users/mike/Documents/darwine/usr/lib/libmpg123.0.dylib
  Referenced from: /Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/
fixme:system:SetProcessDPIAware stub!
fixme:dwmapi:DwmIsCompositionEnabled 0x33c924
fixme:iphlpapi:NotifyAddrChange (Handle 0xa6ef518, overlapped 0xa6ef520): stub
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
wine: configuration in '/Users/paulendres1/.wine' has been updated.
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org

Original comment by alcatr...@gmail.com on 1 Aug 2010 at 7:58

My installation is 2.0.2 and EyeTV 3.4.  It does not work - comskip is running, 
but no commercials are marked. 

I have, as per indicated earlier in this issue, tried to start comskip 
manually.  It works, and it doesn't, in that it initially hangs, and if I then 
give it ctrl-C, it continues and actually analyses the video file.

To wit:

$ "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/wine" "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.exe" --verbose 10 
--ini="/Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" 
000000001270a7f1.mpg 
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org

err:process:__wine_kernel_init boot event wait timed out
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org
^Cfixme:ntdll:RtlNtStatusToDosErrorNoTeb no mapping for c000013a
Comskip 0.80.031, made using:
mpeg2dec-0.4.0 - by Michel Lespinasse <walken@zoy.org> and Aaron Holtzman
The commandline used was:
"Z:\Library\Application Support\ETVComskip\comskip\comskip.exe" --verbose 10 
"--ini=/Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" 
000000001270a7f1.mpg

Opening 000000001270a7f1.mpg
Setting ini file to /Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini 
as per commandline
Using /Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini for 
initiation values.
Setting verbose level to 10 as per command line.
 2:44:53 - 86350 frames in 282.66 sec (305.49 fps), 16.18 sec (2.47 fps), 99%%
86351 frames decoded in 282.68 seconds (305.47 fps)
Commercials were found.

Is the FreeType warning important, or is that just a red herring?  If I try to 
run MarkCommercial manually, it just hangs, like so:

$ /Library/Application\ 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/MacOS/MarkCommercials --verbose 
10 310284900
        MarkCommercials 0.4.0

 1. Processing "Mythbusters" on [Discovery Channel DK] channel [122]...
  Channel: 122 , not skipped
  Title: Mythbusters , not skipped
  Station name: Discovery Channel DK , not skipped

It will stay like that until terminated.  

Here are a couple of log files illustrating the same phenomenon

  Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - /Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.py, 0.4.0 starting
Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - Command line: ['/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.py', 
'--log', '310672500']
Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - Application name: EyeTV
Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - Cfg files read: ['/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/Resources/MarkCommercials.cfg', 
'/Users/bouvin/Library/Application Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.cfg']
Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - List Delimiter: |
Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - Excluded Channels: ['1', '15', '37', '38', '39', 
'3', '20', '21', '24', '29']
Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - Excluded Titles: ['']
Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - Excluded Station names: ['DR1 DK', 'DR2 DK', 'DR HD 
DK', 'DR K DK', 'DR Ramasjang DK', 'TV2 DK', 'TV2 Zulu DK', 'TV2 Charlie DK', 
'TV2 Film DK', 'Viasat History DK']
Fri Nov  5 18:55:13 2010 - Checking communications to EyeTV with 3 retries
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 -   Attempt 1 worked
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 - Getting recordings
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 - Recordings: 
[app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298060800), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(295447213), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(291489300), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(307553100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282855300), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296837713), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(301283713), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302382001), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310248001), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309034513), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309547513), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309639313), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310152313), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(297984452), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(291075301), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(293216118), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(281212500), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(292352100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(291146100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(291747318), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(288723311), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(289328112), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(291909319), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(291996918), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(281813700), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282069901), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298166100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298194914), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(301506913), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(301535713), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(301564513), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302378113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(299619913), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(297893400), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(305485813), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(291322501), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(286138500), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310341313), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(283883701), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282163800), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302622913), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302652003), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302018100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310667113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(304434900), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(286150800), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302709314), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(281591700), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(281418911), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(280786501), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298929600), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(285792911), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282768900), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(285188100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(294429601), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(306237313), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282423311), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(283028100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(252779040), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(288716711), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(288817238), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250949990), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250950112), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250950141), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250950153), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250952542), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250952581), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250957062), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250957110), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250957164), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(250962009), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(259453813), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(249670888), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(249673908), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(249673960), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(249677589), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(249677619), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(249678772), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(249680570), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310067713), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298141501), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298746314), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(299351113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(299955900), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(300560700), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298230900), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302813113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(303576600), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309935701), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310284900), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310326913), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310413313), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310499713), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310672500), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310544100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310586113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310595113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(308768113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(308777113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309330900), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309372913), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309381913), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309977700), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309986713), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310249802), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310267513), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282418201), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(283023000), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(301800014), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(281141100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296711715), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298420800), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(286560000), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(286743300), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(284324111), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298670700), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302561700), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302572500), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(280778111), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(281404501), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310280113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(296607300), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(301521313), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310244700), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310599301), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(306323713), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282428100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282697200), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(301539601), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(308091300), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282509700), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(284140800), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(252785100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(305927701), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310653013), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310518913), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310566613), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(305316001), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(252781500), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(282172200), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(308609113), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(310221013), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(309612913), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(290799611), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(284414701), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(283904100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(284146800), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(301933213), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(286988100), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(298922871), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(302215800), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(284578500), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(285699000), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(285879000), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(287088600), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(286483800), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(284489400), 
app(u'/Applications/EyeTV.app').recordings.ID(286303800)]
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 - Found recording 310672500
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 - Marker count: 0
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 -  1. Processing "Mythbusters" on [Discovery Channel 
DK] channel [122]...
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 - Path to recording is /Volumes/Stormhalten/EyeTV 
Archive/Mythbusters[13].eyetvsched/0000000012847c74.eyetvr
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 - Changing directory to /Volumes/Stormhalten/EyeTV 
Archive/Mythbusters[13].eyetvsched
Fri Nov  5 18:55:14 2010 - Running: "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/Wine.app/Contents/Resources/bin/wine" "/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.exe" --ini="/Library/Application 
Support/ETVComskip/comskip/comskip.ini" "0000000012847c74.mpg" > 
/Users/bouvin/Library/Logs/ETVComskip/310672500_comskip.log 2>&1

and 

  err:process:__wine_kernel_init boot event wait timed out
Wine cannot find the FreeType font library.  To enable Wine to
use TrueType fonts please install a version of FreeType greater than
or equal to 2.0.5.
http://www.freetype.org

Hope you have some suggestions.

Original comment by bou...@gmail.com on 5 Nov 2010 at 7:02

I am seeing this issue again.

EyeTV 3.5
etvcomskip-2.0.2-10.6

I've attached logs and a screenshot of the eyetvsched package.  I'm not sure 
when exactly this stopped working some time in the last few weeks.

Original comment by brandonr...@gmail.com on 12 Jan 2011 at 9:29

Attachments:

[Screen shot 2011-01-12 at 3.28.10 PM.png](https://storage.googleapis.com/google-code-attachments/etv-comskip/issue-35/comment-22/Screen shot 2011-01-12 at 3.28.10 PM.png)
316555140.log
316555140_comskip.log

It looks like I had some issues with commercials not being marked about a week 
or two ago, but it's back to working now. I haven't had time to look into it so 
I don't know what happened.

Dave

Original comment by dave2...@gmail.com on 15 Jan 2011 at 1:52

I'm seeing the same problem.  As you know, I have a hacked up version of 
ETVComskip to accommodate h264 and a MacPorts compiled wine, and was thinking 
that the problem is on my end, but in the file 
/Users/me/Library/Logs/ETVComskip/316922403_comskip.log I see the single error 
line,

err:process:__wine_kernel_init boot event wait timed out

The command

/Library/Application\ 
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/MacOS/MarkCommercials all

works great by hand, just not automatically anymore.

Original comment by steve.t....@gmail.com on 17 Jan 2011 at 3:15

FWIW, tried, without success, recompiling a new wine using "sudo port upgrade 
wine", removing ~/.wine root directory and recreating it using winecfg and 
wineroot --update. This problem persists.

MarkCommercials all works great -- I'm thinking of just setting up a cron job 
to do this every day in the middle of the night, or changing the 
ETVComskip/EyeTV launch command to just run MarkCommercials AFTER the recording 
is done.

Does anyone have a python script up and running for the latter?

Original comment by steve.t....@gmail.com on 18 Jan 2011 at 1:26

One potential cause of this issue seems to be the X11 display variable.  You 
could fix this by

either 1) changing the RecordingDone applescript to set the display variable 
before invoking MarkCommercials:

set cmd to "export DISPLAY=:0.0 /usr/bin/nice -n 2 '/Library/Application
Support/ETVComskip/MarkCommercials.app/Contents/MacOS/MarkCommercials'

or 2) following http://developer.apple.com/library/mac/#qa/qa2001/qa1067.html

$ mkdir ~/.MacOSX
$ touch ~/.MacOSX/environment.plist
$ open ~/.MacOSX/environment.plist

Add child: DISPLAY string :0.0

Save and close. Reboot. Log in. Now, when the script (or any script or shell) 
RecordingStarted.scpt begins and calls "do shell script", the DISPLAY 
environment variable will be set to :0.0, and wine --  which must talk to X11 
-- will work.

-Jon

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 22 Jan 2011 at 12:56

Issue 45 has been merged into this issue.

Original comment by jon.chri...@gmail.com on 22 Jan 2011 at 12:57

essandess / etv-comskip

ETVComskip-2.0-10.6 does not automatically mark commercials when recording is completed #35