search

ethcatherders / EIPIP

EIP Improvement Process
77 stars 38 forks source link

Call for Input: Editor Removal (@axic) #266

Closed SamWilsn closed 9 months ago

SamWilsn commented 10 months ago
Decision Will we remove @axic as an EIP Editor?
Method Unanimous (minus the Editor being removed)
Deadline October 6, 2023
SamWilsn commented 10 months ago

In the interest of not having to wait the full 30 days, I am giving my opinion. Since I'm proposing these rather... rude calls for input, I'm going to abstain from all of them.

abstain.

Pandapip1 commented 10 months ago

I vote no.

SamWilsn commented 10 months ago

I vote no.

@Pandapip1 may I ask why?

Pandapip1 commented 10 months ago

@axic has a unique perspective. I find having a lot of different perspectives to be valuable, even though it necessarily slows down the process.

SamWilsn commented 10 months ago

I 100% value his contributions, but if he doesn't express his opinions on EIP governance related topics, I don't see why we should hold up every formal decision for 30 days.

Pandapip1 commented 10 months ago

@SamWilsn convinced me to change. My vote is a "yes" if @axic does not respond in 7 days, a "no" as soon as he does respond, and an "abstain" in the meantime. If he is removed and wants to re-join, I would support him.

g11tech commented 10 months ago

I 100% value his contributions, but if he doesn't express his opinions on EIP governance related topics, I don't see why we should hold up every formal decision for 30 days.

+1 , would also support re-join

Pandapip1 commented 10 months ago

My vote has now been updated to a "YES", until @axic responds before the CFI deadline.

axic commented 9 months ago

I'd like to stay, even if the environment has been adversarial causing in a decline of my motivation, I do hope to contribute in the near future.

lightclient commented 9 months ago

As long as @axic plans to stick around, I would like to support him as an editor.

Pandapip1 commented 9 months ago

@axic I will change my vote to a "No." As per the most EIPIP meeting, we highly recommend you to delegate the voting power to either another editor or to an "abstain by default" social contract.

g11tech commented 9 months ago

changing vote to No as well

lightclient commented 9 months ago

no

xinbenlv commented 9 months ago

axic, you have authored many important EIPs and reviewed/edited many. Your skills and experience is a great asset to the group. While I understand you are driving a lot of time sensitive core development at the moment, if you could commit to stay and resume EIP editing soon I would personally be very supportive you stay.

Pandapip1 commented 9 months ago

The deadline has passed, and the required votes have not been met. This can be closed.

poojaranjan commented 9 months ago

The proposal could not receive the required votes. @axic will continue to be an EIP Editor.