search

ethcatherders / EIPIP

EIP Improvement Process
77 stars 38 forks source link

EIPIP Meeting 93 #285

Closed poojaranjan closed 8 months ago

poojaranjan commented 9 months ago

Date and Time

Nov 01, 2023 at 14:00 UTC

Location

Zoom: TBA in the Discord #eip-editing channel

YouTube Live Stream/Recording: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4cwHXAawZxpLrRIkDlBjDUUrGgF91pQw

Agenda

1. Discuss Open Issues/PRs, and other topics

Call for Input

Call For Input Status Result Comments
https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/EIPIP/issues/283 Open - Active for collecting responses (till Nov 16)
https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/EIPIP/issues/286 Open - Active for collecting responses (till Nov 19)
https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/EIPIP/issues/287 Open - Active for collecting responses (till Nov 19)
https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/EIPIP/issues/289 Open - Active for collecting responses (till Nov 14)

Changes to Final proposals

Manual Merge TBA

2. Discussion continued or updates from past meetings

3. EIPs Insight - Monthly EIPs status reporting.

4. EIP Editing Office Hour

5. Review action items from earlier meetings

6. Announcement

ERC@Devconnect

lightclient commented 9 months ago

https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/post-eip-erc-split-modification-of-erc-preamble-section/16301/3

Joeysantoro commented 9 months ago

https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/eip-7539-erc-extensions/16152

NetWalker108 commented 8 months ago

https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/post-eip-erc-split-modification-of-erc-preamble-section/16301/3

Additional suggestion: https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/post-eip-erc-split-modification-of-erc-preamble-section/16301/5?u=0xmawuko

NetWalker108 commented 8 months ago

Also @poojaranjan: https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/post-eip-erc-split-represent-each-side-as-camps-in-ethereum-magicians/16271

Joachim-Lebrun commented 8 months ago

https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/post-eip-erc-split-modification-of-erc-preamble-section/16301/3

i created a PR here with the first draft proposition for ERC-1, obviously it is still very far from what it should look like : https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/pull/61

shemnon commented 8 months ago

I think we also need to start having discussions for what other topic groups (peer to EIP and ERC) would look and act like and how they are onboarded. Last week at the same time as the EIPIP meeting was the first "RollCall" for rollup developers and projects to coordinate, so a roll-up top level is a candidate with keen interest. Some questions I don't have strong opinions on that need answers:

xinbenlv commented 8 months ago

@frangio intends to request to update ERC1271. Its security related so I will let him provide the information to the level of details he sees fit

poojaranjan commented 8 months ago

Summary

1. Discuss Open Issues/PRs, and other topics

Topic Group

@SamWilsn responded to questions https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/EIPIP/issues/285#issuecomment-1787706955

Should new topic groups be independent of EIP/ERC or peer within the same structure?

  • It hasn't been set in stone.
  • The way it has been envisioned, they will be peers. ERC | Core-EIPs could become topic / working group.

Start-up: what is needed? an XIP-1 document? Initial editors/stewards?

  • Most of the documentation is written.
  • @SamWilsn will introduce it.

RIP numbering? even/odd won't work. Start from a different number?

  • The current process uses a spreadsheet for numbering.
  • It will be replaced with automated number allocation.

"Boundaries" - how do we determine what group a proposal goes to initially? Is that "portfolio/jurisdiction" baked into the XIP-1 document?

  • Each topic group has sections that describe the area the topic group is interested in reviewing.
  • New proposals will go into the most matching specific topic group.

How do we deal with specs that feel like they belong to multiple groups? Have one group have initial jurisdiction? Multiple specs? Joint specs?

  • Will be determined case by case.
  • The general advice is to go with the closest category.

Next step: @SamWilsn will be publishing the document as soon as possible. Early version here.

EIP-ERC repo split

Update from editors' meeting https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/issues/1

@lightclient shared updates

Decision:

ERC-1

Next step: Document ERC process, make a pull request and it will follow the normal numbering process but the proposal can be redirected from ERC-1 to that number.

Post EIP/ERC split : Modification of ERC preamble section Post EIP/ERC split : Create ERC-1, an ERC specific version of EIP-1 @NetWalker108

E shared his screen and explained the proposal. Most of the people on the call liked the document. Worth following on Fellowship of Ethereum Magicians.

EIP-7539: ERC Extensions discussion @Joeysantoro

https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/issues/8

  • We couldn't discuss it as we ran out of time.

https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/EIPIP/issues/284

Call for Input

Fix a Security related change to a Final EIP

Next meeting: Nov 15, 2023 at 15:30 UTC

poojaranjan commented 8 months ago

Closing in favor of #292