EIPIP Meeting 99

[poojaranjan]

Date and Time

Jan 31, 2024 at 17:30 UTC

Location

Zoom: TBA in the Discord #eip-editing channel

YouTube Recording: EIPIP Meetings

Agenda

1. EIP Process Standardization

• [x] RIP process documentation
• [x] Web Page Rendering to include EIPs, ERCs, RIPs

2. Discuss Open Issues/PRs, and other topics

• [x] https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/pull/213

Call for Input

Call For Input	Status	Result	Comments
https://github.com/ethcatherders/EIPIP/issues/306	Open		Deadline Feb 07, 2024
https://github.com/ethcatherders/EIPIP/issues/308	Open		Deadline Feb 08, 2024

3. Other discussions continued or updates from past meetings

• https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/pull/213

other proposals

4. EIPs Insight - Monthly EIPs status reporting.

• EIPsInsight.com
• Hackmd

5. EIP Editing Office Hour

• Agenda [Meeting 31]

6. Review action items from earlier meetings

• Summary meeting 98

Next Meeting date & time

Feb 14, 2024 at 17:30 UTC

[vittominacori]

I wish this PR https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/pull/213 could be discussed as it is a simple return statement missing for no reason.

[tina1998612]

Hope to discuss ERC7007’s (AIGC token standard) new integration of opml in the next meeting. Thanks:)

[poojaranjan]

@tina1998612

Generally, a PR related to a Final proposal is discussed in EIPIP meeting and ERC-7007 seems to be a new proposal. Could you tell me what you want to talk about?

[poojaranjan]

Summary

1. EIP Process Standardization

RIP process documentation

• No one from the RIP working group joined the call.
• Juan Caballero got a chance to talk to the author of RIP-7212. The author is active in the community, but not part of the RIP working group.
• The community may use some RIP process documentation.

Web Page Rendering to include EIPs, ERCs, RIPs

• @SamWilsn updated that @Pandapip1 has stepped down from the EIP Editors role.
• He further updated with a progress update on working group-based page rendering.
• Still need a decision if this is the official way of page rendering
• @SamWilsn mentioned that he had a chat with Ansgar and they seem pretty interested in seeing RIP as a working group rendering.
• @gcolvin shared his support for the working group rendering.
• Juan mentioned that Ullas (author of RIP-7212) at the time, didn't seem to know about the roles and responsibilities of the working group. People are already committing to other conversations.
• He shared links to "what working group meant".
• @SamWilsn shared a high-level overview of a working group. More can be found here and here
• @gcolvin shared concerns over some of the existing policies like "external link policy"
• @SamWilsn demoed the working group page

2. Discuss Open Issues/PRs, and other topics

https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/pull/213

• @SamWilsn & @g11tech are okay to merge it.
• PR can be merged at the end of the day.

Call for Input

https://github.com/ethcatherders/EIPIP/issues/306

• Deadline Feb 07, 2024
• @g11tech it can become a spam vector or maybe an issue to allow a new EIP to say that it supersedes or updates a particular EIPs
• Juan mentioned that there are multiple extensions of ERC-20 already.
• @g11tech will hesitate to pop these links on ERC-20 page.
• @SamWilsn suggested having a UI to showcase how the forward links will look like.
• @poojaranjan thinks of proceeding with another proposal similar to ERC-233, to update the security vulnerability found in 1271 and educate the community about that. Updating a Final EIP may not be needed.
• Lot of back-and-forth argument, no decision.
• Editors please add your comments to come up with a decision by the end of the deadline.

https://github.com/ethcatherders/EIPIP/issues/308

• Final EIP where the existing author wants to add a new author.
• @gcolvin perhaps the authorship wasn't acknowledged when it should have been, if so - errata
• @g11tech thinks that EIP authorship is not a credit-giving system. The Final EIP does not require any further editing, so no need to update.
• @gcolvin thinks it adds value to individual resumes. However, @g11tech thinks it may open a Pandora's box of such cases of updating authors later on.
• No decision, editors may add their comments.

Call For Input #291 & #293 can be closed.

4. EIPs Insight - Monthly EIPs status reporting.

EIPsInsight.com Hackmd

Next Meeting date & time

Feb 14, 2024 at 17:30 UTC

[vittominacori]

Hi @poojaranjan @SamWilsn @g11tech so will the https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/pull/213 be merged? Thanks.

[poojaranjan]

Closing in favor of #312

[vittominacori]

@poojaranjan sorry to bother you, I can't understand if that PR https://github.com/ethereum/ERCs/pull/213 will be merged or not.

It says

PR can be merged at the end of the day.

but it is still open.

[poojaranjan]

@vittominacori There was no objection on the call for it to be merged. I have pinged EIP editors for the same on the EIP-editor channel on ECH Discord.