search

ethcatherders / PM

103 stars 60 forks source link

Ethereum Cat Herders Meeting #110 #355

Closed poojaranjan closed 1 year ago

poojaranjan commented 1 year ago

Date and Time

June 06, 2023 at 14:00 UTC [Please note the change of meeting time]

Location

Join Zoom Meeting https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84834303064?pwd=YTVDNUxvSjEzL1VTOXNoNmI1a2RlZz09 Video at YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCD9iiIwTRtLDYcEWONs2Q3A

Agenda

New users on ECH Discord and/or contributor's introduction

1. Ethereum network upgrades

Useful resources

Other Protocol Development & Research

4. New initiative/association

5. Review of outstanding action items from previous ECH meetings

The date for the next meeting is June 20, 2023

(If anything else, leave a comment.)

pcaversaccio commented 1 year ago

I have continually documented in the (currently closed) EIP-6269 why it is relevant to reconsider this, and numerous people have also shown support, e.g. on Twitter (I have linked some of them) & @xinbenlv also can see my arguments why it is important (see his comments here). I kindly ask you to reconsider your decision as I really think it is wrong to close this important, definitional EIP.

xinbenlv commented 1 year ago

I have continually documented in the (currently closed) EIP-6269 why it is relevant to reconsider this, and numerous people have also shown support, e.g. on Twitter (I have linked some of them) & @xinbenlv also can see my arguments why it is important (see his comments here). I kindly ask you to reconsider your decision as I really think it is wrong to close this important, definitional EIP.

Yes, given the context of zkEVM, I think it's worthy to reopen this discussion about defining what's considered "EVM compliance"

Also we shall discuss it to be whether an informational or meta EIP?

poojaranjan commented 1 year ago

@pcaversaccio Just for you to know, EIP editors decide to merge or not merge a proposal to the EIPs repository. Should you want to discuss this proposal with them, my recommendation will be to add a comment to the EIPIP meeting Agenda. If possible, join the meeting; if not, leave an explanation.

pcaversaccio commented 1 year ago

@pcaversaccio Just for you to know, EIP editors decide to merge or not merge a proposal to the EIPs repository. Should you want to discuss this proposal with them, my recommendation will be to add a comment to the EIPIP meeting Agenda. If possible, join the meeting; if not, leave an explanation.

Thanks! I added it to the agenda with an explanation.

poojaranjan commented 1 year ago

Closing in favor of #358