search

ethereum / eth2.0-pm

ETH2.0 project management
Other
260 stars 75 forks source link

Eth2 protocol upgrade naming theme brainstorming #202

Closed hwwhww closed 3 years ago

hwwhww commented 3 years ago

We need a code name!

The next Eth2 major upgrade (a.k.a hard fork) was tentatively named "HF1" in the current spec. To effectively communicate and connect with the community, we should come up with a distinct name soon. ✨

Moreover, it would be cool to have a unique naming theme to link all future releases together!

The following comments are some candidates I've collected. If you have an awesome idea, please comment here! 🙌

Dear community members, please signal your opinions with positive emojis! ❤️ 👍 🚀

Deadline of proposals and initial signals: 2021-02-22 @ UTC 02:22

Hint: Some properties of a good theme/name

hwwhww commented 3 years ago

Candidate 1: Chemical elements

Examples

Hydrogen, Helium, Lithium, ...

Proposer

Hsiao-Wei Wang (@hwwhww)

Notes

hwwhww commented 3 years ago

Candidate 2: World of Warcraft Zones

Examples

A: Azshara/Ashenvale/Arathi, B: Badlands/Blasted Lands, C: ?, D: Desolace, E: Elwynn Forest, F: Feralas/Felwood...etc.

Proposer

Vitalik Buterin (@vbuterin)

Notes

WoW!

hwwhww commented 3 years ago

Status updated: Retracted

Candidate 3: Any collection of mythical objects

Examples

  • Mythical astronomical objects/planets
  • Mythical weapons (not friendly?)
  • Mythical trees
  • Mythical musical instruments

Proposer

Diederik Loerakker (@protolambda)

edsonayllon commented 3 years ago

Candidate 4: Star names

Examples

Sirius, Altair, Arcturus, Antares, ...

Proposer

Edson Ayllon (@edsonayllon)

Notes

Ethereum 1 upgrades are named after cities. I'd like to continue the theme of physical locations, but do so with a different kind of physical locations. I'm thinking star names. Then, we can move onto galaxies for Eth3.

Editor log: @hwwhww edited it for aligning the proposal format. :)

q9f commented 3 years ago

Candidate 5: Solar Systems

Examples

Pator, Rens, Dal, ...

Proposer

Afr Schoe (@q9f)

Notes

protolambda commented 3 years ago

Retracting my naming suggestion. Mythical astronomical objects/planets may as well just be astronomical objects/planets/stars/solar systems. Let's just make sure we don't overlap with something like Cosmos though.

lightclient commented 3 years ago

Candidate 6: City Names

Examples

Amsterdam, Berkeley, Cario, ...

Proposer

Matt Garnett (@lightclient)

Notes

superphiz commented 3 years ago

Candidate 7: Months of the Year

Examples

January, February, March ...

Proposer

superphiz

Notes

timjp87 commented 3 years ago

Candidate 8: Ordinal Numeral

Examples

First, Second, Third ...

Proposer

timjp87

Notes

prestonvanloon commented 3 years ago

Candidate 9: Semantic Versioning

Examples:

Proposer:

Preston Van Loon (@prestonvanloon)

Notes:

mauroaccornero commented 3 years ago

Candidate 10: Space missions/programs

Examples:

timjp87 commented 3 years ago

Candidate 11: Geological Time Scale

Examples:

Proposer:

timjp87

Notes:

ladidan commented 3 years ago

Candidate 12: Instruments

Examples

Proposer ladidan

Notes

mohsenghajar commented 3 years ago

Candidate 13: Popular video games

In the order of release date of the first version of the game.

Examples:

  1. Pong
  2. Pac-Man
  3. River Raid
  4. Wolfenstein
  5. Dune

pros:

cons:

mikeyme454 commented 3 years ago

I think hf1 naming convention could be cool relative to string theory. Strethereum... ETH & SETH 😁..DUNNO ..the string theory framework definition is inline with ETH's hard fork fixes and it's cool and simple 😎.. it's a good name ..

String theory::

In physics, string theory is a theoretical framework in which the point-like particles of particle physics are replaced by one-dimensional objects called strings. String theory describes how these strings propagate through space and interact with each other.

Fuck parachains

derbaltasar commented 3 years ago

Candidate 14: Human hormones especially neurotransmitter families like tryptamines, these family of molecules is such interessting thing, cause there will be science.... wait this is such a interessting thing, I don't know where to start... ok I start with the lesser interessting things, and try to increase the Level of interesst for everybody similarly.

To the chemical familly of the tryptamines, you can count a lot of molecules. And some of them are known well, the most known tryptamine is seretonine, everyone should have heard of it, or maybe: melatonine, it is maybe not the only neurotrans handling diziness... but the most known and I think most known about. If it is dark the melatonin begins to be formed by enzymes and if you sitting on a couch your eyes will be hard to keep open... if it's light, "the third eye" (german word for pineal gland) stops producing Melatonin and your ready for work or having very active sex or what ever..... All these tryptamines are produce by a gland, called the pineal gland... There are only 2 glands in the brain which exists only one time, the pineal gland and the epitalamus. All other parts of the brain has two parts, right and left. The pineal gland produces also an other molecule which is much MORE fascinating. The name is Dimenthyltryptamine. Dr. Rick Strassman which was the first western scientist getting such a deep inside in a world which is beyond ours, not only this, this world seems to be build by every beeing inside it, if the beeings are aware about what they are.... consciousness and of course not in the everyday awareness. You can also reach this states of mind through meditation is better cause you can controll it and already grown spiritually that maybe you won't need the experiences anymore.. But if you wanna do it that way, and I will never negotiate the fact that reaching these states of consciousness by meditating.... BUT for this states you must do a long journey through a mostly thoughtless state of mind, which is very hard these days and why, I think I don't must tell you. Look 1 min in the TV if you have one, then you know what i mean, and then throw it out of the window...Believe me, you won't need it, it is only an addiction, and you don't have to be treated, maybe some people, those who already watch things like the jungle camp (german bull shit). Or no people watching such thing are still lost forever, you can only shoot em....

I hope i won't shock some people, cause please realize, halluzinogen drugs have no addictive potential.... the opposite is the case, for example in the USA the Indians are still allowed to do their rituals, which includes also the psychoactive peyote or San Pedro cacttus, both include mescalin. The Shamans often try to get friends of friends to come cause they are addicted , mosty from optiates. The People with addiction often drink only a little bit, cause they got fear what the Meskalin will show them. I had always a sentence for me, no matter how deep i was in the rabbit hole, these words help for real! (normal I tell it in german -> "Du erlangst erst die Kontrolle wenn du aktzeptierst dass es keine gibt" in English "You only reach control in the moment you realize that there is no control" This senctence I created in the time (about 20 month) in which i only took weed and LSD every weekend, If there had been no tollerance you build against substances, I would have take it everyday. Then this part of my life ended and a year later I tried the first and only time ayahuasca. A friend of mine, is from Brasilia and was writing with a peruish shaman . After 2 week of writing, he was sure that we dont do shit wtihit, and we really never had a thiought about that. I also hated the storrys when a guy was tripping and need help cause he/she is getting his/herself deeper in the pychological abyss... I was a guy, helping everybody, who needed help. And I hated storrys about guys which didn't help but did the opposite!

So I must write not so much, I come know to the scientific things, cause Dr. Strassmann found out that our third eye produces the DMT in high dosis, when we are born as a little baby, and in the moment we die... and sometimes we dream special dreams in which DMT is also involved. Strassman wrote a book, really goood, named DMT-Molecule of Consciousness. The Interessting thing is also that the experiences made by the probands are similar to near death experiences, if you would read 2 of them, after you can't say which is the DMT experience and which is the neardeath xp....

From these experiences you can bring knowledge from these dimensions back in our allday life, it could be a thinking trick to get better talking with your mum, but also technical stuff, I think very much scientists couldn't invent their biggest inventions without the help of tryptamines (I forgotto tell that every indogene people from all over the world, found a healing plant which all contain a tryotamin.... Only today with science an chemistry we can understand the similarity between the plants, and if the iindogen people, and that the plants must be anything special, why should medicinmen from around the world, without communication! Choose the plants for spiritual and physical healing.

Amazonas -> Ayahuasca -> MAO-Hemmer + 5-Meo-DMT + DMT Mexico -> Pilze -> Psilocybin/Psilocin Afrika -> Ibogain-Wurzel -> Ibogain SouthAmerika -> Aga-Kröte, uvm. > Bufotenin

When I talked about the scientists, of course most of these cases won't get known, cause it's like being a pilot and telling your cheef that you saw 3 UFOs the last flight.... määääp unemployed! Ok as a scientist, maybe it is not so hard, I know one, and you all know him indirect... the founder of the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR), which were the first tests for the fake virus which is used to make unethical Laws, and so much more, I would need again 1000 words.... Kary Mullis got the Nobelprice in 1993 for his invention in 1983. And only cause he is a man of truth, they already talk shit about him on wiki....

From the beginning he said, his method is not able for testing viruses, no good sentence from the inventor of PCR, put how lucky are the pharma companies... in his autobiography he wrotes "that without LSD he think he wouldn't have the nobelprice..."

Please realize, this is the guy who brought us DNA, the whole cop DNA evidence things and so won't work without his work. And the pharmasa have no better job to peach a good scientiest which also died 2 years ago... So no chance to defend himself.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kary_Mullis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tryptamine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epithalamus

Ok I hope anybody understand my proposal, ---> I would like the name Tryptamine :)

dmichulke commented 3 years ago

Candidate 15

Moons: Luna, Europa, Ganymede, ... Reasoning: 50+% of the user base aim for exactly this

Candidate 16

Attacks on the chain: 51% attack, malleability issue, double spend Reasoning: Robotraders might interpret this negatively and create a setback in price

Candidate 17

Name of Cryptocurrencies in order of market cap ("The bitcoin hard fork of ethereum", ...) Reasoning: Confuse everyone

Candidate 18

The old 4 elements: Earth Fire Water Wind Reasoning: Ether is the fifth element

editor log: @hwwhww updated the proposal format a bit. :)

apertamono commented 3 years ago

Tip: Monero creates distinctive names by using double names for hard forks. See the naming convention and the releases. Chemical elements are used in the order of the periodic table (with one exception), followed by a celestial object chosen shortly before the fork, with a preference for alliteration. Of course it would be appreciated if Ethereum used a different scheme.

For more inspiration, I have a collection of naming schemes including links to other sources.

@superphiz @dmichulke Maybe you'd like the list of Star Trek characters, where Number One (from the pilot episode) is the third name.

AroundTheBox commented 3 years ago

Candidate 19: Mountains

Using mountain names conveys the difficulty of getting to each release and the achievement when each is conquered.

Choosing names around the world shows the global nature of Ethereum, so starting with the seven peaks you’d have Aconcagua, Denali, Everest, Kilimanjaro, etc.

It’s of course easy to create an alphabetical list - Annapurna, Bogda, etc.

editor log: @hwwhww updated the serial number. :)

henkevdb commented 3 years ago

Candidate 20: Esperanto numbering

The word esperanto translates into English as "one who hopes" ; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Esperanto

https://www.languagesandnumbers.com/how-to-count-in-esperanto/en/epo/

editor log: @hwwhww updated the serial number. :)

uberchar commented 3 years ago

Candidate 21: Spaceships/Spacecrafts

Both fiction and non-fiction Examples: Hyperion, Millennium Falcon, Curiosity

Reason: Everyone is searching for moonshots may as well be the ship that takes you there. Beacon chain + shards are like a flagship + smaller ships

AroundTheBox commented 3 years ago

Candidate 22: Fictional Materials

Vitalik came up with the name for Ethereum looking at a list of fictional materials, so why not do the same for ETH 2.0 forks?

We can easily come up with an alphabetical list: Adamantium, Beskar, Computronium, etc.

hwwhww commented 3 years ago

@hwwhww forwarding the proposals for a friend.

Foreword

I assert the two largest criteria for an eth2 naming conventions are:

  1. Topical / on-theme (science, utopian futurism, technology, exploration, etc.) Think something that conveys the spirit of the current ethereum.org design.
  2. Memeability. We want a theme for which it takes low effort for the community to generate memes. Dogecoin is obviously the king here. But another is Polkadot, where they represent their brand simply by an attractive person wearing polkadot clothing with various facial expressions.

Given these two constraints, I propose two possible themes:

Candidate 23: Galaxy and Celestial Objects

Proposer

Anonymous

Examples

There was a prior proposal that we use stars instead of galaxies and then use galaxies for eth3. I respond that galaxies are more photogenic than individual stars, so why not just jump to that. And for keeping galaxies for eth3, I presume the ethereum tastemakers will prefer deciding their own theme instead of one being dictated by the past. Yay empowerment.

Pros

Cons

hwwhww commented 3 years ago

@hwwhww forwarding the proposals for a friend.

Candidate 24: Names or objects from Sci-Fi media

Proposer

Anonymous

Examples

Pros

Cons

lfgarske commented 3 years ago

Candidate 25: Characters in drama

Examples Ariel, Beatrice, Cordelia, Demetrius... (Characters of The Tempest, Much Ado About Nothing, King Lear, A Midsummer Night's Dream...)

Proposer Lucas Garske (@U203D)

Notes Since the development of a complex projects entails not only pleasure but also a lot of drama, characters in drama could work as a suitable theme for upcoming releases. Many plays are universal, regardless of time and space. Since there are a lot of plays to choose from, it is possible to find references to current development steps and by doing so "characterize" the corresponding step of development. Needless to say that the final step should probably a character from a comedy rather than a tragedy :)

Pros: Alphabetical order, lots of material, leeway to add meaning to a particular development step Cons: Characters not easily recognizable for most people.

schajose commented 3 years ago

Candidate 26: People who changed the world in a positive way, in alphabetic or time order.

What happens now is "changing the world". So lets continue history into future

Example: Mandela Curie Einstein King Da Vinci Jesus Theresa Gandi Orwell Gallileo ...

Souptacular commented 3 years ago

Candidate 27: Famous animals from movies and TV shows

Proposer

Hudson Jameson

Examples

Pros

Cons

Souptacular commented 3 years ago

Candidate 28: The word "ethereum" but with an alphabetical letter in front of it and exclamation point at the end

Proposer

Hudson Jameson

Examples

Pros

Cons

LamboshiNakaghini commented 3 years ago

Candidate 29: Simply express each hardfork as a phase of Eth2.

Proposer

Lamboshi

Examples

Phase 0 Phase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3

This upcoming hardfork would be phase 0.

Pros

Simple Clear Concise

Cons

Can't think of any. Happy to hear feedback.

poapxyz commented 3 years ago

### Candidate 30: The word freedom in different languages

Proposer

Patricio Worthalter

Examples

Frihed (Danish) Libertad (Spanish) Freedom (English) vapaus (Finnish) özgürlük (Turkish) wolność (Polish) ñembisy (Guarani) Kalayaan (Tagalog) Others: https://www.freelang.net/expressions/liberty.php

Pros

Mission driven Lots of options Easy to associate a flag a emoji with Quite unique

Cons

Lots of similarity between lenguages for example German is Freiheit and Duth is Vrijheid.

isaac-art commented 3 years ago

Candidate 31: Seasame Street Muppets

Examples Abby Cadabby Beautiful Day Monster Count von Count Don Music more

Proposer Isaac Clarke

Notes Cons: Theres only about 100 or so.

Phistr90 commented 3 years ago

Candidate 27: Famous animals from movies and TV shows

Proposer

Hudson Jameson

Examples

  • Eeyore
  • Flit

Come one. We all know that F would have to be Flipper.

KevinVitale commented 3 years ago

Candidate 32: Year & Month (Ubuntu Style)

Examples

Proposer

@KevinVitale

Pros:

Cons:

A2be commented 3 years ago

Candidate 10: Space missions/programs

Examples:

  • Apollo
  • Biomass
  • Curiosity

Proposer:

Mauro Accornero (@mauroaccornero)

Notes:

  • Represent the efforts and sacrifices of people working on an ambitious project.
  • Not focused on a single country, ESA for example, have a good list like other countries.
  • Allow custom characterization, supported by a single mission/program purpose and history.
  • Maybe can give good inspiration for more ideas.

A large con on this is that nearly all space programs during the first six+ decades since humans came to possess the technology of spaceflight were a) government agency space programs and b) done by the gvmts of the richest/most-powerful nation states, totally missing much of the global population. Neither comports with what Ethereum is all about, or the ethos of the Ethereum ecosphere.

The SpaceX/Elon Musk privately-funded programs to develop reusable rocket technology, and to build a Mars transportation infrastructure system are exceptions. However both are too new; and the Mars program is only in its infancy with an uncertain future.

This "con" applies only to the large historical and current space programs. Naming Eth2 releases after stars, galaxies, globular clusters, or stellar nurseries, are all pretty awesome ideas.

Buttaa commented 3 years ago

Candidate 33: Emojis

Proposer Butta

Examples :heart : fork ❤️ :new_moon : fork 🌑 :fork_and_knife : fork 🍴

Pros: emojis are easy to memorise covers many categories (fruits, cars, flags..)

Cons: ¯_(ツ)_/¯

superphiz commented 3 years ago

With the naming of the first hard fork being the most critical component of release, I propose that all work on other issues should halt until a name has been chosen.

A2be commented 3 years ago

Candidate 34: Name after various stellar nurseries of the astrophysical space-time that surrounds us. Ethereum emerges new protocols and projects, just like stellar nurseries do.

Proposer

@A2be

Examples

Pros

Cons

Phistr90 commented 3 years ago

Candidate 35: Name after oldest lighthouses

Examples For oldest (according to https://www.oldest.org/structures/lighthouse/):

Proposer @Phistr90 aka phil.eth

Pros

Cons

Phistr90 commented 3 years ago

Candidate 36: Name after tallest lighthouses

Examples For tallest lighthouses (according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_lighthouses):

Proposer @Phistr90 aka phil.eth

Pros

Cons

vbuterin commented 3 years ago

Candidate 37: names of countries in mismatched languages

Proposer: @vbuterin

Examples:

  1. Angleterre
  2. Frankreich
  3. Niemcy
  4. Lengyelország
  5. Mađarska

(in this order to preserve chaining)

Pros

Cons

Candidate 38: characters and places in Studio Ghibli movies

Proposer: @vbuterin

Examples:

Pros

Cons

hwwhww commented 3 years ago

[Announcement] The deadline of proposals and primary signals: 2021-02-22 @ UTC 02:22

CarlBeek commented 3 years ago

Candidate 39: Powers of g1

Examples:

0x97f1d3a73197d7942695638c4fa9ac0fc3688c4f9774b905a14e3a3f171bac586c55e83ff97a1aeffb3af00adb22c6bb
0xa572cbea904d67468808c8eb50a9450c9721db309128012543902d0ac358a62ae28f75bb8f1c7c42c39a8c5529bf0f4e
0x89ece308f9d1f0131765212deca99697b112d61f9be9a5f1f3780a51335b3ff981747a0b2ca2179b96d2c0c9024e5224

Proposer:

@CarlBeek

Notes:

Pros:

Cons:

ghost commented 3 years ago

Candidate 40: Jupiter's Moons

Examples:

  1. Europa
  2. Ganymeade
  3. Io
  4. Callisto
  5. etc....

Proposer: @Logic_Beach

Notes: I really like the massive expanse of astronomical names there are to choose from. Also, seeing as ETH is 'mooning' let's go with moons!!!

Pros:

Cons:

None?
greg7mdp commented 3 years ago

Candidate 41: Names related with Light

Interestingly beacon in Beacon Chain means a signal light

The next fork which adds support for light clients could simply be codenamed Light.

There are many light related scientific terms that would make nice codenames. Some made up examples:

Light related scientific names or things

There are many light related proper names with varied meanings which can be used:

and there are many others, see here for examples.

proposer: me :-)

Dessix commented 3 years ago

Candidate 42: Fermions and Bosons of the Standard Model

Multiple orders are available, from increasing energy to positioning in the standard model and date of confirmation.

Examples currently discovered:

Pros

Cons

hadv commented 3 years ago
  • the fork making ETH resistant to quantum algorithms: quantum (or quanta)

@greg7mdp do you have detail document about this?

greg7mdp commented 3 years ago
  • the fork making ETH resistant to quantum algorithms: quantum (or quanta)

@greg7mdp do you have detail document about this?

I just made up forks that sounded possible (to me), I don't believe there is any plan for this one in particular.