Closed wackerow closed 1 year ago
wackerow
commented
1 year ago https://web.archive.org/web/20221206144249/https://docs.ethhub.io/
^ Link to the latest web archive of the page.
@jmcook1186 We may also want to peak at this and see what content we may have been linking out to that we aren't anymore, and see if there are gaps in our own content that we should consider filling.
0xKai27
commented
1 year ago Found one on the "What is Ether" page that is being rendered via the eth.tsx and translation files.
UI:
eth.tsx:
corwintines
commented
1 year ago Would a good interim be using the wayback link, and then looking for new sources to update after?
0xKai27
commented
1 year ago Based on your list above, did a run-through with comments below. In general, given the load times required for archive retrieval, recommend to migrate uncovered topics found in EthHub to ethereum.org. For the majority of topics which intersect, ethereum.org usually has more comprehensive and updated information but a side-by-side review can be done if there is value in integrating EthHub content into existing ethereum.org pages.
[x] #9148 : https://ethereum.org/en//community/get-involved/#write-content - Propose to remove as it points users to update EthHub which is being sunset
[x] #9154 : https://ethereum.org/en/community/research/#background-reading-2 - Most of the scaling concepts are already covered in ethereum.org in greater depth. If needed, a review can be done to migrate EthHub resources but value add will be limited. Propose to remove link and conduct a review to integrate EthHub content with ethereum.org scaling docs instead
[x] #9149 : https://ethereum.org/en/contributing/style-guide/#style-guide - EthHub is being used as an example in a code block. Propose to change this example to another well-known resource such as an article from the Consensys blog
[x] #9186 : https://ethereum.org/en/defi/#main-content - The EthHub DeFi resources are largely revolving around specific implementations rather than concepts. ethereum.org has greater details regarding the concepts. Propose to add EthHub examples to the ethereum.org dapps page if still relevant. To be tracked under #9146 instead with regards to adding dapps.
[x] : https://ethereum.org/en/deprecated-software/ - Note that this page is not indexed by ethereum.org search. No changes required
[x] #9198 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/consensus-mechanisms/pow/mining/#further-reading - As Ethereum has switched to PoS, the included EthHub link still maintains its relevancy as a historical archive. As such, updated EthHub link to point to the web archive snapshot on 17/09/22. Additionally, added a section on ommer blocks to give further context to readers that might have come across the "uncle" term when Ethereum was still under PoW.
[x] #9150 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/gas/#further-reading - ethereum.org page on gas already addresses the concerns in greater detail. Propose to remove link
[x] #9153 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/nodes-and-clients/run-a-node/#further-reading
[x] #9185 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/nodes-and-clients/#further-reading - ethereum.org staking page is comprehensive enough to achieve the desired outcome. Propose to remove link to avoid confusion
[x] #9151 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/oracles/#further-reading - ethereum.org doc on oracles is more comprehensive. Propose to remove link
[x] #9188 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/scaling/optimistic-rollups/ - Ethereum.org is more comprehensive and reflects developments in the optimistic rollup space since the EthHub resource was updated. Propose to remove link.
[x] #9201 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/scaling/plasma/ - EthHub contains a section on the different plasma flavours. As Plasma solutions are being phased out in favour of rollups, I have decided that the additional info would not be of significant value to the ethereum.org page as it adds significant details to an outgoing topic. Open to suggestions if the community thinks otherwise. Propose to remove link
[x] #9187 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/scaling/sidechains/ - ethereum.org resource covers all the points raised on EthHub. Propose to remove link
[x] #9199 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/scaling/state-channels/ - EthHub has additional details surrounding specific implementations. Concept-wise, ethereum.org is easier to follow and more comprehensive. Propose to include Raiden as an external link as an example of a payment channel on Ethereum. Propose migration of EthHub data not found on ethereum.org. Propose removal of the 2 EthHub links (state channel & payment channel)
[x] #9189 : https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/scaling/zk-rollups - The ethereum.org zk-rollup page is more comprehensive and easier to reason with. EthHub's resource assumes knowledge of plasma chains but the industry has since moved towards a roll-up centric framework (i.e. newer users are more familiar with rollups instead of plasma). Propose to remove link
[x] #9200 : https://ethereum.org/en/governance/#on-chain-vs-off-chain - EthHub goes into greater detail on on-chain vs off-chain governance but lacks details surrounding EIPs & DAOs when compared to ethereum.org Propose to migrate on/off-chain resource to ethereum.org governance page and remove link
0xKai27
commented
1 year ago I can work on the above if it makes sense. Will be a good refresher on the concepts while migrating the resources
Describe the bug
According to this tweet the EthHub project is being sunset. Currently the ethhub.io domain appears to already be down.
We have several links on ethereum.org that point to this resource.
To reproduce
Expected behavior
The links on our page should be removes or updated to make sure we're not pointing to broken links
Screenshots
Desktop (please complete the following information)
No response
Smartphone (please complete the following information)
No response
Additional context
No response