search

ethereum / go-ethereum

Go implementation of the Ethereum protocol
https://geth.ethereum.org
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
47.51k stars 20.11k forks source link

Enhancing bind.WaitMined and bind.WaitDeployed Functionalities with Customizable Wait Interval for Transaction Monitoring #29317

Closed 0xJord4n closed 7 months ago

0xJord4n commented 7 months ago

Certainly! Here's the enhanced message with an addition addressing the need to edit the WaitDeployed function, which relies on WaitMined:

Rationale

The inclusion of this feature is paramount to enhancing the flexibility and adaptability of both the WaitMined and WaitDeployed functions within the go-ethereum repository. By introducing a customizable wait interval, developers gain the ability to tailor transaction monitoring to suit a myriad of use cases. This feature's existence ensures that Ethereum-based applications can efficiently monitor transaction statuses while accommodating diverse network conditions and application requirements.

Use-Cases:

  1. Real-Time Transaction Monitoring: Applications requiring instantaneous confirmation of transactions, such as decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms or gaming applications, benefit from customizable wait intervals. Developers can adjust the monitoring frequency to ensure timely responsiveness, thereby enhancing user experience and application performance.

  2. Optimized Resource Utilization: Customizable wait intervals enable developers to optimize resource consumption during periods of network congestion. By adjusting the interval duration based on network conditions, applications can minimize unnecessary polling, leading to efficient resource utilization and reduced operational costs.

  3. Batch Transaction Processing: Applications performing batch transactions or bulk operations often require flexible monitoring intervals. Customizable wait intervals allow developers to tailor monitoring frequency to the specific needs of different transaction batches, optimizing processing efficiency and ensuring timely execution.

  4. Cross-Chain Interoperability: Projects facilitating interoperability between Ethereum and other blockchains benefit from adaptable monitoring intervals. By adjusting the wait interval based on the target blockchain's characteristics, developers can ensure efficient asset transfers while maintaining interoperability across heterogeneous networks.

Implementation

Ideas for Implementation:

  1. Introduce a waitInterval Parameter: Modify the WaitMined and WaitDeployed functions to include a waitInterval parameter, allowing developers to specify the duration between status checks.

  2. Default Value Setting: Define a reasonable default value for the waitInterval parameter to ensure ease of use for developers who do not explicitly specify a custom interval.

  3. Documentation Update: Update relevant documentation to provide clear instructions on utilizing the customizable wait interval feature and its impact on transaction monitoring behavior.

Willingness to Implement:

I am enthusiastic about contributing to the implementation of this feature within the go-ethereum repository. I am committed to ensuring that the proposed changes align with best practices and meet the diverse needs of Ethereum developers. Collaboration and feedback from the community are welcomed to refine the implementation and ensure its effectiveness in real-world scenarios. Additionally, I acknowledge the need to edit the WaitDeployed function to accommodate the changes made to WaitMined, ensuring consistency and compatibility across the codebase.

MariusVanDerWijden commented 7 months ago

I wrote some arguments why this is not needed in my opinion in the PR.