Fact-check some stuff - Githubissues

evebrnd / eps

Project carried out as part of the EPS semester at Oslo Metropolitan University. This is an educational site that aims to raise awareness on smart home devices' privacy and transparency

https://evebrnd.github.io/eps/

MIT License

1 stars 0 forks source link

Fact-check some stuff #69

Closed Jappie3 closed 4 months ago

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

[x] Provide a source for this (video data to train facial recognition) https://github.com/evebrnd/eps/blob/a91d6209cb9689fe407ad498d69cec477ce9a93b/src/app/chapters/four/page.tsx#L586
[x] This line is contradictory: don't apple & google have an opt-in policy? https://github.com/evebrnd/eps/blob/a91d6209cb9689fe407ad498d69cec477ce9a93b/src/app/chapters/four/page.tsx#L551
[x] Provide a source for this (data to law enforcement) https://github.com/evebrnd/eps/blob/a91d6209cb9689fe407ad498d69cec477ce9a93b/src/app/chapters/four/page.tsx#L598
[x] The word 'speaker' does not even appear in this article? or am I blind? https://github.com/evebrnd/eps/blob/a91d6209cb9689fe407ad498d69cec477ce9a93b/src/app/chapters/four/page.tsx#L628

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

another thing to check:

[x] where did this number come from? https://github.com/evebrnd/eps/blob/570aa59ea372474b0c2d2ed4244d6e963a171137/src/app/chapters/six/page.tsx#L213

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

[x] source? https://github.com/evebrnd/eps/blob/570aa59ea372474b0c2d2ed4244d6e963a171137/src/app/chapters/six/page.tsx#L277

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

[x] https://github.com/evebrnd/eps/blob/570aa59ea372474b0c2d2ed4244d6e963a171137/src/app/chapters/six/page.tsx#L304

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

@ItsNotDaan @Mellevandijk01 do you guys have the sources for these claims somewhere? they're all from your chapters (no offense xD)

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

just coincidentally stumbled upon this: https://apnews.com/article/ring-doorbell-camera-settlement-ftc-payments-658a3bae14c4744cf449932099dc4404 - can be used for the first point

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

data to law enforcement: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/ring-will-no-longer-allow-police-to-request-doorbell-camera-footage-from-users

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

BBC link should be https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-47893082, not https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-47974579

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

the 75% comes from here: https://www.aarp.org/home-family/your-home/info-2021/home-and-community-preferences-survey.html

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

washington post source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/02/18/ring-nest-surveillance-doorbell-camera/

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

data to law enforcement: https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/13/amazon-gave-ring-videos-to-police-without-owners-permission-00045513 https://www.npr.org/2022/07/23/1113166744/amazon-says-its-given-information-from-ring-cameras-to-police-without-owners-con https://www.wired.com/story/ring-police-rfa-tool-shut-down/

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

closing

Jappie3 commented 4 months ago

oops