Contribution: supervised the data analysis, analyzed the data, contributed analysis tools, wrote the paper, edited and reviewed drafts of the paper.
Contribution:
Jim Steadman
L.36: ...that can be ~a~ yield-limiting...
L.37: Comment --- Resistance has been identified but not in commercial beans
L.85: The early nursery
L.96: ddH2O for 3 min.
L.393: While the evidence may suggest host...
L.490: MCG does not necessarily represent...
Contribution: Conceived and designed experiments, organized network of white mold screening nurseries, provided S. sclerotiorum isolates, edited and reviewed drafts of the paper.
B. Sajeewa Amaradasa
L.67: isolates collected over 10 years between 2003 and 2012
L.72: ...effect of cultivar on genetic diversity of the pathogen by assessing...
L.116: Question: is this ~2.5cm? If you say >2.5cm, what is the upper limit? (ZNK: perhaps I worded this incorrectly; perhaps: "removing plant growth beyond 2.5 cm above the fourth node.")
L.253: Comment: better to give absolute numbers since P<0.05 can be 0.0001, too.
L. 261: Comment: Is this for Year, Host, and MCG? If so, better to mention that or remove region and just mention P ≤ 0.007
L.277: ...effect for MLHs (P = 7.44e^-4^) ~for MLHs~, with means that...
L.341: Did Carbone and Kohn study temporal structure as well? (ZNK: no, they did not investigate that)
L.462: What is the substrate others have used?
Contribution: analyzed the data, contributed analysis tools, wrote the paper, edited and reviewed drafts of the paper.
Serena McCoy
L.122: Replace with more specific language --- Each mycelial mat was collected in a filtered Büchner funnel
Acknowledgements: Becky should also be acknowledged for the lab and greenhouse work she did.
Contribution: Carried out and experiments (MCG assessment, aggressiveness ratings, genotyping), edited and reviewed drafts of the paper.
Sydney Everhart
Contribution: supervised the data analysis, analyzed the data, contributed analysis tools, wrote the paper, edited and reviewed drafts of the paper.
Contribution: Jim Steadman
L.36: ...that can be ~a~ yield-limiting... L.37: Comment --- Resistance has been identified but not in commercial beans L.85: The early nursery L.96: ddH2O for 3 min. L.393: While the evidence may suggest host... L.490: MCG does not necessarily represent...
Contribution: Conceived and designed experiments, organized network of white mold screening nurseries, provided S. sclerotiorum isolates, edited and reviewed drafts of the paper.
B. Sajeewa Amaradasa
L.67: isolates collected
over 10 yearsbetween 2003 and 2012 L.72: ...effect of cultivar on genetic diversity of the pathogen by assessing... L.116: Question: is this ~2.5cm? If you say >2.5cm, what is the upper limit? (ZNK: perhaps I worded this incorrectly; perhaps: "removing plant growth beyond 2.5 cm above the fourth node.") L.253: Comment: better to give absolute numbers since P<0.05 can be 0.0001, too. L. 261: Comment: Is this for Year, Host, and MCG? If so, better to mention that or remove region and just mention P ≤ 0.007 L.277: ...effect for MLHs (P = 7.44e^-4^) ~for MLHs~, with means that... L.341: Did Carbone and Kohn study temporal structure as well? (ZNK: no, they did not investigate that) L.462: What is the substrate others have used?Contribution: analyzed the data, contributed analysis tools, wrote the paper, edited and reviewed drafts of the paper.
Serena McCoy
L.122: Replace with more specific language --- Each mycelial mat was collected in a filtered Büchner funnel
Acknowledgements: Becky should also be acknowledged for the lab and greenhouse work she did.
Contribution: Carried out and experiments (MCG assessment, aggressiveness ratings, genotyping), edited and reviewed drafts of the paper.