exeldro / obs-downstream-keyer

GNU General Public License v2.0
106 stars 20 forks source link

[Feature Request] Make "None" the 1st List Item #29

Open rasamassen opened 11 months ago

rasamassen commented 11 months ago

Right now "None" is part of the options at the bottom (with a non-obvious icon - why not a circle with a slash cancel symbol?). For my operators (volunteers at a church), it would be much more intuitive if "None" was the 1st List Item in each tab.

Even if this was an optional setting, it would be helpful.

exeldro commented 11 months ago

The pause icon is used because I wanted to use an icon that is part of OBS so it would work in every theme. You can create an empty scene called None in OBS and add that to the DSK. You can drag that scene to the top if you want it as first item.

Moulaythami commented 5 months ago

Hi @exeldro, First thank you a thousand time for your time and work, it's helping a thousand a people all around the world. I believe that @rasamassen was thinking of a feature like this :

screenshot

It may be kind of difficult to implement. But it's true that could be easy for operators to switch between a lot of keyers. Have a great day 👍

rasamassen commented 4 months ago

I like @Moulaythami idea, but I imagine it would result in lots of accidental clicking. At this point, we're defaulting to a custom "none" for the first option in each of our tabs, but there's no clear indication to our operators when a tab is at "none" or it's at another option.

I think what I want is like @Moulaythami idea, but with a visible icon when anything in that tab is visible. Then, when selecting the "None" first option or clicking stop (instead of pause) at the bottom, the visible icon would disappear. That would provide clear indication to the operators which tabs are currently displaying an option and which ones are not.

(the stop icon would be a lot more intuitive than the pause icon; disabling the icon when on none would help too)

dunronet commented 2 months ago

The pause icon is used because I wanted to use an icon that is part of OBS so it would work in every theme. You can create an empty scene called None in OBS and add that to the DSK. You can drag that scene to the top if you want it as first item.

Being able to Incorporate "None" as a List Item (or multiple list items) would be awesome as it would help my assistant keep track of where we are in the program. It's not as simple as adding a blank Scene though. E.g. if you want transitions to behave differently. (e.g. Fade in a lower third, fade it out [current pause icon], but don't fade between lower thirds)