search

exelix11 / SysDVR

Stream switch games to your PC via USB or network
GNU General Public License v2.0
1.46k stars 89 forks source link

No audio playback and video glitches when the window is resized on MacOS #234

Closed c01dc0ffee closed 1 year ago

c01dc0ffee commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug MacOS users with libSDL2 version 2.26.5 report no audio playback and visual glitches if they resize the player window.

To Reproduce Set up a SysDVR stream on MacOS. All streaming modes and players appear to be affected.

Expected behavior Game audio should playback as normal and the stream window should be resized without encountering visual artifacts at the frame borders.

Setup information

Additional context One user reported success with using an unofficial build of mpv, presumably because it ships with libSDL2-2.0.0.dylib. Downgrading libSDL2 might fix this, but it's unclear if this is something that can be fixed in SysDVR. I can't find anything related to this in the SDL issue tracker.

exelix11 commented 1 year ago

There have been a few reports about htis on discord so it's somewheat known, my stance on this is:

There is essentially nothing i can do about it since on other platforms it seems to work just fine. If someone affected by this wants to test they could try older versions of sysdvr to see if the problem persists, based on the result of that i can think of the next steps.

One user reported success with using an unofficial build of mpv, p

mpv and external video players are unrelated from sysdvr, i'll only be addressing issues related to the builtin player of sysdvr and possible encoding quirks. If stock mpv doesn't work on macos it's out of scope for me.

exelix11 commented 1 year ago

I'd rather keep this open so it shows up on searches since discord messages tend to get lost

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

This issue is stale because it has been open for 30 days with no activity.

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

This issue was closed because it has been inactive for 14 days since being marked as stale.

kvn1351 commented 11 months ago

There have been a few reports about htis on discord so it's somewheat known, my stance on this is:

  • We don't know how many users are actually affected nor the total macos usersbase so it's hard to know the impact of this
  • We don't know if this is sysdvr-specific or an SDL bug
  • Since i don't have a mac (and i'm not getting one for this lol) the limited number of users make it hard to debug the issue

There is essentially nothing i can do about it since on other platforms it seems to work just fine. If someone affected by this wants to test they could try older versions of sysdvr to see if the problem persists, based on the result of that i can think of the next steps.

One user reported success with using an unofficial build of mpv, p

mpv and external video players are unrelated from sysdvr, i'll only be addressing issues related to the builtin player of sysdvr and possible encoding quirks. If stock mpv doesn't work on macos it's out of scope for me.

If you want I could prepare a VM (vmware, qemu or virtualbox) for you running macOS and all libs/deps so you'd just have to spin it up. That would save you lots of time.

I've tried with libSDL2-2.0.0 but that didn't do the trick either :/

exelix11 commented 11 months ago

The notification reminded me, we have a fix for this now but it's coming with the next major update which will still take some time.

In the meantime I'll try to backport the fix to the current release

kvn1351 commented 11 months ago

The notification reminded me, we have a fix for this now but it's coming with the next major update which will still take some time.

In the meantime I'll try to backport the fix to the current release

Oh, that's great :)

Thanks a lot