f1multiviewer / issue-tracker

Issue and feature requests tracker for MultiViewer for F1
https://multiviewer.app
103 stars 1 forks source link

GP Radio (Netherlands) #438

Closed Deojuvente closed 1 year ago

Deojuvente commented 1 year ago

When I use Multiviewer, I cannot access the menu option in GP Radio, which says 'Radio channel with Dutch commentary. Not available in the Netherlands due to licensing restrictions.' However, when I visit the website directly, I can listen live without using a VPN (https://grandprixradio.be/radio-luisteren). Why does Multiviewer indicate that there are licensing restrictions?

martijnvankekem commented 1 year ago

As the application says, there are licensing restrictions. If you visit the Grand Prix Radio website, a banner tells you it's exclusively available in Belgium.

The fact that the official website doesn't country-restrict listeners, doesn't mean it's against their policy. MultiViewer allowing users to listen to it from other countries would be a policy violation which would possibly bring the developer(s) in trouble.

JustJoostNL commented 1 year ago

Hey,

However, when I visit the website directly, I can listen live without using a VPN

If you open the commentary stream on the website in the Netherlands (without VPN), it checks if you have access to the commentary stream, when not it will play the normal music stream. So I assume you heard the music instead of the commentary?

MultiViewer won’t play the music stream when you don’t have access to the commentary stream, which results in no audio playback.

Also, about the following:

The fact that the official website doesn't country-restrict listeners

This isn’t true, GP Radio does allow access to the commentary stream to all countries except the Netherlands (they block the Netherlands specifically).

Also all the blocking is on GP Radio’s end, and MultiViewer doesn’t block anything, it only displays the warning.

f1multiviewer commented 1 year ago

Going to close this as not planned.