I want to preface this by saying I'm not sure this is the right spot for a report, but since I can make this work in environments -outside- of Carla, it seems a good starting point.
I'm trying to remap Midi CC using x42's midifilter cc map -- hardware to hardware, but via USB with a saved Carla session. (So very luxuriously convenient!)
For the example: Source hardware is generating CC control 10 on channel 16. I want to remap that to CC 13 on channel 1. I'm sending to jack_midi_dump for demonstration:
Output looks like so:
314: bf 0a 42 control change (channel 15): controller 10, value 66
371: bf 0a 41 control change (channel 15): controller 10, value 65
502: bf 0a 42 control change (channel 15): controller 10, value 66
94: bf 0a 43 control change (channel 15): controller 10, value 67
254: bf 0a 44 control change (channel 15): controller 10, value 68
467: bf 0a 45 control change (channel 15): controller 10, value 69
442: bf 0a 46 control change (channel 15): controller 10, value 70
84: bf 0a 47 control change (channel 15): controller 10, value 71
It just doesn't seem to map. If I try and do something similar in Ardour (with the same plugin) it works properly. Additionally, if I load the plugins in jalv and just use Carla to perform the routing, it also works. It feels like the problem only appears when using Carla as the LV2 host.
I've tried this under Carla 2.5.5 (from kxstudio repo) and a locally built 2.5.6, and removed the hardware entirely and just using mididebug to emulate. Not that that would necessarily matter, but hey.
Happy to try any other methods for debug/reproduction offered.
Heya!
I want to preface this by saying I'm not sure this is the right spot for a report, but since I can make this work in environments -outside- of Carla, it seems a good starting point.
I'm trying to remap Midi CC using x42's midifilter cc map -- hardware to hardware, but via USB with a saved Carla session. (So very luxuriously convenient!)
For the example: Source hardware is generating CC control 10 on channel 16. I want to remap that to CC 13 on channel 1. I'm sending to
jack_midi_dumpfor demonstration:Output looks like so:
It just doesn't seem to map. If I try and do something similar in Ardour (with the same plugin) it works properly. Additionally, if I load the plugins in jalv and just use Carla to perform the routing, it also works. It feels like the problem only appears when using Carla as the LV2 host.
I've tried this under Carla 2.5.5 (from kxstudio repo) and a locally built 2.5.6, and removed the hardware entirely and just using mididebug to emulate. Not that that would necessarily matter, but hey.
Happy to try any other methods for debug/reproduction offered.