featurecat / lizzie

Lizzie - Leela Zero Interface
GNU General Public License v3.0
959 stars 227 forks source link

Feature-request: Winrate display and blunderrings on gametree. #183

Open WYVYW opened 6 years ago

WYVYW commented 6 years ago

Some SGF-Editors (like Drago) show move-numbers on the gametree.
image

Would it be possible to show the winrate on the stones of the gametree?

featurecat commented 6 years ago

Smart... it adds to the idea of displaying information on the stones themselves as Lizzie already does. This supplements the winrate graph nicely. This can make it into 0.6 or 0.7, most likely. Any other ideas for displaying information in the game tree?

WYVYW commented 6 years ago

"Blunderrings" is another idea, but a bit more complicated to explain and include. The value of "last move" now displayed in top left of Lizzie could be displayed as rings in the following picture. image. redder-brighter-bigger=blunderrer image The SGF-editor Drago uses rings to show the group status of stones. I would use these rings in the gametree so one can instantly see the biggest blunders in the gametree. If -5 would be the biggest failure of the game, than that would be the glowing red ring. If -20 would become the biggest failure, than -20 stones would get the brightest red ring and -5 a less visible ring. Green might be used for a positive value.

Lecale commented 6 years ago

The parameters should be customisable in my opinion. By default show only red for swing greater than 15 Allow parameters for orange and yellow

WYVYW commented 6 years ago

Some good players may never have big swings (but big mistakes in their opinion), some rookies might have almost always have more than 15. To find the biggest mistakes under different circumstance values should be relative.