search

fedidcg / fedidcg.github.io

Website and charter of the Federated Identity Community Group
https://fedidcg.github.io
9 stars 4 forks source link

Charter: test suites? #20

Open martinthomson opened 11 months ago

martinthomson commented 11 months ago

I see no mention of test suites. From our perspective, that alone would result in a formal objection if this charter were up for a vote.

hlflanagan commented 10 months ago

@martinthomson Are you talking about web platform tests or are you referring to something else? We agree that tests are necessary, but would like to make sure we're clear as to which tests are required to be mentioned in the charter.

samuelgoto commented 10 months ago

+1, generally speaking.

We have put in place a good amount of Web Platform Tests here, is this more or less what you are looking for to be represented in the charter?

martinthomson commented 10 months ago

I have a slight preference for WPT, especially given that this is already in progress. I just want the charter to require tests before something is considered fit for publication.

hlflanagan commented 10 months ago

I've proposed a few updates to the charter text, including moving the desire for test suites from non-normative to a normative requirement for web platform tests. See https://github.com/fedidcg/fedidcg.github.io/pull/21.