feedbin / support

83 stars 11 forks source link

Missing Articles on fivethiryeight.com #555

Closed benubois closed 7 years ago

benubois commented 7 years ago

fivethiryeight.com is using dc:identifier for author URLs. I think this is a mistake, because as I understand it, dc:identifier should uniquely identify an entry. I sent the following to contact@fivethirtyeight.com:

Hello,

This is a support request for the web development team.

I work on an RSS reader called Feedbin, https://feedbin.com.

Recently several customers have reported an issue with missing updates from fivethirtyeight.com RSS feeds.

I think the issue has to do with the recent addition of the dc:identifier element to fivethirtyeight.com’s feeds.

fivethirtyeight.com is using this element as a link to the author bio, however I think is incorrect and is causing an issue.

According to "RSS and Atom: Understanding and Implementing Content Feeds and Syndication” https://goo.gl/ZzBA29 the value for dc:identifier is supposed to be a unique identifier similar to a guid. A guid uniquely identifies RSS entries so repeating the same guid makes articles that share the same dc:identifier look identical.

It would be great if the feeds could be updated to not use dc:identifier in this way.

Thanks!

Ben Ubois

nbousfield commented 7 years ago
benubois commented 7 years ago

Thanks @nbousfield!