search

feilipu / Arduino_FreeRTOS_Library

A FreeRTOS Library for all Arduino ATmega Devices (Uno R3, Leonardo, Mega, etc).
MIT License
854 stars 204 forks source link

what is the difference of three freertos? #104

Closed youxiaojie closed 3 years ago

youxiaojie commented 3 years ago

https://github.com/feilipu/Arduino_FreeRTOS_Library https://github.com/feilipu/miniAVRfreeRTOS https://github.com/feilipu/avrfreertos and the original rtos kernel avr ports https://www.freertos.org/a00098.html ?

feilipu commented 3 years ago

AVRfreeRTOS contains all the options and library code I use with my Uno, Mega2650, and Goldilocks 1284p platforms. There are many options for different memory management and even Xtended RAM support on Mega. It is all the code I've built up over some years.

MINIfreeRTOS is cut down to the bare minimum, mainly to see which files are needed. It could be used as a base, but is more of a reference than something working.

ArduinofreeRTOS is tuned to work with all ATmega devices (that I can support with avr-libc). But it loses control over many things to fit into Arduino IDE environment. Most critically, the preferred Timer can't be used, as the WDT is all that is available to be system tick. But it works quite well and can be a good start to learn about FreeRTOS.

I initially built ArduinofreeRTOS to enable me to use Arduino libraries and drivers, but not lose my preferred FreeRTOS capabilities.

youxiaojie commented 3 years ago

take 328p/uno as example,it.can use avrfreertos and arduinofreertos. in arduino ide in arduino libs select arduinofreertos, inavrgcc with avrlib using avrfreertos? right?

and because of arduino libs , the prefered timer can't be used?

feilipu commented 3 years ago

AVRfreeRTOS cannot be used with Arduino IDE. I use Eclipse IDE, and hence there are no make files etc.

Arduino configures all timers in its standard libraries. If you steal one for FreeRTOS system tick something in the libraries will break, or the compile will fail.

youxiaojie commented 3 years ago

http://marketplace.eclipse.org/content/arduino-create-eclipse-plug

http://marketplace.eclipse.org/content/arduino-eclipse-ide-named-sloeber-product

which one can run your avrfreertos？not arduinofreertos from lib manager.

feilipu commented 3 years ago

Read the posts here. https://feilipu.me/2011/09/22/freertos-and-libraries-for-avr-atmega/