Closed itowlson closed 2 years ago
vdice
commented
2 years ago Not sure if this will be helpful at all, but may at least be informative if the behavior is different: It looks like Hippo supports specifying a particular spin binary path.
Could we try adding something like Spin__BinaryPath = "<path to spin on host>" to the Hippo job env, re-run start.sh and see if behavior changes?
itowlson
commented
2 years ago @vdice Hmm, interesting! That fails with:
2022-06-16T10:24:43+12:00 Driver Failure failed to launch command with executor:
rpc error: code = Unknown desc = file /home/ivan/github/spin/target/debug/spin
not found under path /home/ivan/github/fermyon-installer/local/data/nomad/alloc/8a8d6670-ba70-c433-f00f-92d1d84fc4d2/spinThanks @itowlson.
It appears that configuration is meant to represent a relative path in the allocation (cc @bacongobbler to check my understanding) and so perhaps not helpful here.
My only other idea is to see if we can try overriding the Nomad:Driver value. Not sure if it is resolving to exec or raw_exec for you (OperatingSystem.IsLinux()). Does setting Nomad__Driver = "raw_exec" help?
itowlson
commented
2 years ago I am not sure how to test that given that Hippo is downloaded rather than taken from a local copy - is there something I can set in the installer to force it?
itowlson
commented
2 years ago > System.OperatingSystem.IsLinux();;
val it: bool = trueI'm not sure if exec or raw_exec makes a big difference. I tried these two jobs:
job "spin-raw-exec" {
datacenters = ["dc1"]
type = "batch"
group "spin-raw-exec" {
task "spin-raw-exec" {
driver = "raw_exec"
config {
command = "spin"
args = []
}
}
}
}
job "spin-exec" {
datacenters = ["dc1"]
type = "batch"
group "spin-exec" {
task "spin-exec" {
driver = "exec"
config {
command = "spin"
args = []
}
}
}
}and both failed, although with different statuses: exec gave me the "file spin not found" message, raw_exec gave me "Terminated: exit code 2".
itowlson
commented
2 years ago Oh! spin without arguments looks like it might return exit code 2. Maybe raw_exec worked and I just looked for logs in the wrong place!
itowlson
commented
2 years ago @vdice YES! raw_exec works for my demo case - I just got confused by the output. But it looks like Hippo is sending me exec. Is there a way to override the Hippo setting so I can test this with a real Spin app?
vdice
commented
2 years ago 🎉 Excellent! I wonder if raw_exec is a prereq for WSL -- and if so, if we can conditionailize things so that the installer just works for this case (or, actually, maybe the conditional in Hippo is a better fit 🤔).
Anyways, to the task at hand. Yes, it should be an env setting on the hippo job similar to the spin binary path we tried above.
Try adding Nomad__Driver = "raw_exec" to the Hippo job env.
itowlson
commented
2 years ago 🎉 IT WORKS 🎉
I can now bring up Nomad and Hippo, but when I do a
spin deploy, the application (the Spin job goes into Unhealthy.The status information for a typical Spin job is: