OBDII BT Dongle test - Githubissues

fesch / CanZE

Take a closer look at your ZE car

http://canze.fisch.lu

Other

123 stars 70 forks source link

OBDII BT Dongle test #29

Closed solmoller closed 8 years ago

solmoller commented 9 years ago

We are going to have a lot of people testing this app with various dongles. Apart from a list of known good/bad dongles in the hardware section on the wordpress site, we could add a test to the setup menu.

I suggest adding a button at the end of the BT setup: 'Test'. Pressing it makes the app issue ATZ

and display the result, in my case 'innocar' Then issue: ATSH 7E4
and display both the result and an interpretation : 'OK 5 bytes read - that looks good' Then issue: ATFCSH 7E4
again display the result and an interpretation : 'OK - two times OK, it appears you have a working adapter'

We might go as far as to do some speed testing, but that is outside what I can describe

Henrik

fesch commented 9 years ago

Good idea :-)

yoh-there commented 9 years ago

OK, I will take that challenge on.

On Tue, Sep 22, 2015 at 7:11 PM, Bob Fisch notifications@github.com wrote:

Good idea :-)

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/fesch/CanZE/issues/29#issuecomment-142352272.

fesch commented 8 years ago

The best place to do this is place a button in the Settings menu that is only visible/enabled if ELM327 is selected.

yoh-there commented 8 years ago

I agree

yoh-there commented 8 years ago

ELM test is now fully implemented in the Playground (Jeroen). Give it a spin, and I'll move it to the Setting screen later.

yoh-there commented 8 years ago

After some consideration I think we should leave ELM testing in experimental (or a third category, something like "technical" or "advanced", where also DTC should be moved once we're a bit more sure it works.

I am closing this issue.

Edit: most important reason for closing is that our straightforward advice is to buy a KW902. Not much need to test anyway, that one works.