search

ff-meli / OrchestrionPlugin

Simple BGM management plugin for XivLauncher
MIT License
12 stars 45 forks source link

missing 1.0 main city themes #28

Open Punbunbunpun opened 2 years ago

Punbunbunpun commented 2 years ago

I couldnt find the 1.0 uldah theme { The Twin Faces} and 1.0 limsa lominsa them { Navigators Glory} :)

edgarhighwind commented 2 years ago

I asked around on the CMTool discord, and as far as they know, it's not possible to add these themes. The 1.0 city themes are never used as background music, and thus they only exist in the orchestrion folder, rather than also sitting in the BGM folder. The orchestrion folder is mono format, while the BGM folder is stereo format. Unless either the CMTool or Meli wants to chime in, I think we're unfortunately out of luck as far as orchestrion-only music is concerned. (To be clear: not trying to imply "blame" or anything with this comment. Just pointing out how it appears that 1.0 city themes are out of scope for these projects.) If I hear anything different, will update this issue page.

lmcintyre commented 2 years ago

Please note that this repository for the plugin is not being maintained, and this issues page is not monitored. Issues should be brought up here: https://github.com/lmcintyre/OrchestrionPlugin

As mentioned, this plugin cannot play tracks from the in-game Orchestrion, it plays songs that the game uses as BGM. Since the Orchestrion system is quite convoluted, it would take quite a bit of research to implement. In addition, this may bypass in-game paywalls for listening to music, which brings it into a copyright gray area.