fiboa / specification

Field Boundaries for Agriculture (fiboa) - a specification that describes important properties of field boundaries
Apache License 2.0
10 stars 3 forks source link

Relation to other standard #35

Open m-mohr opened 5 months ago

m-mohr commented 5 months ago

e.g. see https://adaptstandard.org/docs/

From out internal chat:

It seems like there's Working Group 17 - Field Boundary use cases & definitions in AgGateway. We are already using their definition for determination_method, see also #31 It seems parts of it should go into https://adaptstandard.org/ - see also https://github.com/ADAPT/Standard/issues/97 I think we should clarify what our relation is and how we can benefit from each other to not reinvent well-thought out definitions etc. They also have data types and schema definitions, which I still need to dig into: https://adaptstandard.org/docs/#get-started (bearbeitet)

Alternatively, other "commonly used" ones:

m-mohr commented 2 months ago

Interesting discussion today with Stuart Rhea and Ben Craker. Very fruitful and helpful.

This document is interesting and we'll probably borrow parts of it: https://aggateway.org/Portals/1010/WebSite/About%20Us/FIELD%20BOUNDARY%20FLYER%20122123.pdf?ver=2024-01-03-212959-590

Generally, I think we can re-use a couple of definitions from ADAPT on the property level. The hierarchy will probably be difficult to adapt into a non-hierarchical specification (e.g. crop zones for field boundaries). Nevertheless, going through https://adaptstandard.org/docs/ and checking for potentially useful things is the next step. I'll go through and see what could be useful.

We plan further calls. The documentation is MIT licensed according to https://github.com/ADAPT/Standard