search

filecoin-project / FIPs

The Filecoin Improvement Proposal repository
313 stars 165 forks source link

FIP-0093: Set the Mining Reserve to Zero #1039

Open jnthnvctr opened 2 months ago

jnthnvctr commented 2 months ago

Abstract: The mining reserve was intended to be a reserve of tokens to incentivize future types of mining. In the spec, this is noted to potentially "not be enough" and that the community will "decide whether to make adjustments with unmined tokens".

This proposal seeks to remove the mining reserve. This does not preclude new tokens from being created - rather that any new incentives should be created at the point when new forms of mining are introduced rather than relying on a set of pre-minted tokens.

Discussion: Link

jennijuju commented 2 months ago

The first editor pass is ✅ - need clarification on what "remove" means in multiple places and is missing product, security and incentive considerations (see the template here); The rest is clear to me.

anorth commented 2 months ago

Please take FIP number 0093. Update the filenames and text to match that.

The-Wayvy commented 1 month ago

Can we put this in last call?

jennijuju commented 1 month ago

Can we put this in last call?

The authors have to address editors reviews for this fip to land as a valid DRAFT first.

anorth commented 1 month ago

@jnthnvctr are you still on this or have you abandoned it (and why?). You have a bunch of editor feedback to address, but nothing that would prevent a perfectly good FIP coming out of this that can then be properly put to the community for discussion and governance process.

My impression is that there are many people in support of this idea, but they're currently pseudo-blocked from doing anything constructive with it because you "own" it having drafted this FIP. Would you please follow through? Alternatively, if you abandon it and make it clear that it's merely because you have lost interest, the space will open up for someone else to take over.

jnthnvctr commented 1 month ago

bleh - didnt mean to close this out, was trying to incorporate the changes onto the fork (makign the edits here - will try and figure out how to undo and link back here so we can keep the thread)

rvagg commented 1 month ago

With some precision in details around new total supply and minor whitespace cleanups this lgtm ✅ 🚢