filecoin-project / notary-governance

114 stars 58 forks source link

Removal of notary BlockmakerOnline from the Filecoin plus program #956

Closed cryptowhizzard closed 4 months ago

cryptowhizzard commented 1 year ago

Based on multiple flags from the community in the T&T WG slack, calls as well as open disputes in the tracker, the following notaries is being recommended by me for removal from the main multisig

Especially since expressing ignorance towards other notaries in the community in issue 1935

It is community consensus that applications who are under dispute should not be signed. This specific application uses SP's who are known in LDN 1556 / 1557 / 1558 / 1559 and do not support retrieval.

Timeline The timeline for proposed changes will be two weeks, by Aug 14th.

Technical dependencies RKH is required to add/remove notaries

End of POC checkpoint (if applicable)

BlockMakeronline commented 1 year ago

You should be removed because you're making the whole community discordant. Can you create one for yourself? I think you'll get a more complete picture of yourself.

huang-Cora commented 1 year ago

image

I think I'm being framed by @cryptowhizzard . Our application-1935 has no dispute. Retrieval is successful! https://github.com/filecoin-project/filecoin-plus-large-datasets/issues/1935#issuecomment-1661534707

Can you just do anything before you jump to conclusions?

raghavrmadya commented 1 year ago

@BlockMakeronline , can you please respond to the dispute with objective facts and evidence?

BlockMakeronline commented 1 year ago

We tried data retrieval before, and it worked. We've tried it again, and it worked again.

mmexport1691888363285 (1)
BlockMakeronline commented 1 year ago

Hi, @raghavrmadya Is there anything I need to provide?