search

finity69x2 / fan-control-entity-row

Provides a means to show a compact graphical control row for 2 or 3 speed fans in Home Assistant
68 stars 27 forks source link

Off state not working #20

Closed boojew closed 4 years ago

boojew commented 4 years ago

EDIT: seems I misunderstood how sendStateWithSpeed was supporsed to work. That is not the issue...

I have a MQTT based fan that, for some reason, will not turn off when using v1.5 of this plugin w/ hass 0.110. Works w/ my 3 other Insteon based fans. From what I can see the service call fan.turn_off doesnt seem to be sufficient, but rather the fan expects fan.set_speed set to off..

boojew commented 4 years ago

Playing around a bit, I am wondering if calling the speed is a better approach? Not sure. Perhaps there should be a variable. I essentially just changed line 208 to this.hass.callService('fan', 'set_speed', {entity_id: this._config.entity, speed: speed});

And it solved my issue and also worked for my other fans. What do you think?

finity69x2 commented 4 years ago

which mqtt based fan is it?

if you go to the services tab and select the fan.turn_off service and put in your entity_id for your fan does the fan turn off when you call the service?

boojew commented 4 years ago

It’s a zigbee fan through zigbee2mqtt. I’ve tried calling the service, but it does not stop.

finity69x2 commented 4 years ago

Sorry for all the questions but I'm trying to fully understand the situation before making changes...

If you use a regular entity row for the fan controls and click on the toggle switch for the fan are you able turn the fan off from there?

Inkedex4

and if you can what does the speed shown in the drop down menu below that say?

boojew commented 4 years ago

Yea, it doesnt work.. Perhaps this is actually more of a Zigbee2Mqtt issue in the way the fan domain is implemented Before turning off image After turning off image

Setting the speed as off does work

finity69x2 commented 4 years ago

Yeah I think it is a zigbee2mqtt issue.

Does that fan happen to be a Hampton Bay fan controller?

I just bought one of those a week ago and it gives me the exact same "speed list".

I have it connected to my system using the ZHA integration and it works the same as the rest of my fans do and works fine with my control row config.

ex1

boojew commented 4 years ago

Yea, that's the fan!

finity69x2 commented 4 years ago

then it has to be a problem with zigbee2mqtt since mine is working perfectly using the control row with it connected via ZHA.