search

finos / community

FINOS Community, Project and SIG wide collaboration space
http://community.finos.org
66 stars 28 forks source link

DevOps Mutualization Vote - Should we consider DevOps Mutualization a Special Interest Group now SIGs have been introduced to FINOS? #61

Closed mcleo-d closed 4 years ago

mcleo-d commented 4 years ago

DevOps Mutualization Vote

Please vote on this issue with a 👍 or +1 if we should consider DevOps Mutualization a Special Interest Group now SIGs have been introduced to FINOS.

DovOps commented 4 years ago

In order for everyone to help facilitate informed voting, @mcleo-d can you please share the implications of this decision (vs not going in this direction)?

mcleo-d commented 4 years ago

Thanks for your feedback @DovOps. Please find below FINOS documentation on Special Interests Groups that could help answer the question. I'll add more information as we progress through the call 👍

jbjonesjr commented 4 years ago

Wikipedia defines a Special Interest Group as

A Special Interest Group (SIG) is a community within a larger organization with a shared interest in advancing a specific area of knowledge, learning or technology where members cooperate to affect or to produce solutions within their particular field, and may communicate, meet, and organize conferences.

Not one to love citing the wiki in the sky as a primary source, but we seem to fit all the qualification questions:

The key question to me, "Is this a working group or a Special Interest Group", right now, we seem tightly scoped enough to be a SIG, with perhaps a path to WG later. If someone can find more official LF program differentiation of a SIG vs a WG, you're google-fu is better than mine!

In light of that, i'm 👍 to proposing this as a SIG

mcleo-d commented 4 years ago

@DovOps, @jbjonesjr and Team,

Please find below the FINOS definition of a Special Interest Group (SIG) that I've highlighted from the following FINOS Governance document - https://github.com/finos/community/blob/master/governance/README.md

Special Interest Groups

Special Interest Groups can be proposed by any FINOS Member (and only by FINOS Members) and are approved by the Governing Board, which also appoints the initial SIG chair. Over time the SIG can decide to vote in a new Chair or the Board can appoint one. Read more for a list of current SIGs and how to propose a new SIG.

Community Governance

FINOS also hosts Special Interest Groups (SIGs) which are forums where community members sharing an interest in a certain topic discuss ideas, compare experiences, and consider common solutions (which may or may not take the form of new open source software or standards projects).

All FINOS projects and SIGs are expected to observe the FINOS Collaborative Principles, Meeting Procedures and recommended to follow Branding Guidelines.

// ---

Comparing the FINOS definition to @jbjonesjr's wikipedia definition, FINOS SIGs aren't obliged to produce physical materials and can keep the scope to sharing thoughts and experiences only.

If a SIG decides to produce physical materials, this can be done within the SIG or done as an independent project created as a SIG recommendation.

I hope that helps with the vote?

Produce Solutions: We can only hope! 🚀🚀🚀

mcleo-d commented 4 years ago

Hi,

The question Should we consider DevOps Mutualization a Special Interest Group is closing on Wednesday 9th September 2020 since being opened on 29th July 2020.

Please cast your vote with a thumbs up 👍 on the main body of the issue here ... https://github.com/finos/community/issues/61#issue-667777109

For those wanting the definition of a Special Interest Group, this can be found below ...

FINOS Governance : Community Governance FINOS Special Interest Groups are forums where community members sharing an interest in a certain topic discuss ideas, compare experiences, and consider common solutions (which may or may not take the form of new open source software or standards projects).

To directly answer @dovops question ...

In order for everyone to help facilitate informed voting, @mcleo-d can you please share the implications of this decision (vs not going in this direction)?

The implications of creating a DevOps Mutualization Special Interest Group is that the group will be recognised by the FINOS board and will be provided with access to the FINOS community, the mechanisms and infrastructure to operate and the platform needed to distribute future potential work.

Without the above, DevOps Mutualization will not be housed or supported by the foundation.

I look forward to receiving your vote.

James.

mindthegab commented 4 years ago

Can I suggest to name the SIG "Regulated DevOps" or "Compliant DevOps" or even "RegDevOps" and just drop mutualization? Meaning it's kinda obvious we're looking to mutualize, we're an open source community :)

mcleo-d commented 4 years ago

Hi all,

I have now officially closed DevOps Mutualization issue https://github.com/finos/community/issues/61#issue-667777109 after receiving 9 successful votes that provide a positive yes answer the following question ...

Should we consider DevOps Mutualization a Special Interest Group now SIGs have been introduced to FINOS?

Thank you for voting on this question, which will now be taken to the FINOS board for their feedback and potential SIG approval.

James.