animationstart hook not effective if lazy loaded

[calinoracation]

We are asynchronously loading, so the start event has already happened when the polyfill loads in Safari.

I tried various workarounds like waiting for the polyfill to load and switching from play state paused to running.. Perhaps completely not applying until then is an option, but that's tricky for authors.

My current workaround is to apply a data attribute to each element and once loaded query them all and call play on the animations. That does seem to work.

[calinoracation]

Turns out this is also a problem when we fetch remote stylesheets. The stylesheets themselves are already loaded, but the animationstart event we use to hook into it has already fired after we parse the stylesheets from fetch.

[flackr]

We can use document.getAnimations() and search for all running animations that are an instanceof CSSAnimation and upgrade them. This should handle animations which were already in progress when the polyfill sets up the animationstart listener.

[calinoracation]

I tested this out and that works except for the condition of them running. Most of them have a default duration of 1ms for it to work in Safari so the play-state was not set to running. Otherwise this works like a charm!

[flackr]

Maybe we could temporarily change the fill mode to forwards or both before calling getAnimations() to ensure that even finished animations are still in effect. We could change it back immediately after calling getAnimations to ensure that the change is never visually seen.

[flackr]

An alternate option would be to have a very small snippet that is run synchronously which simply collects a list of started animations and then passes them in to be set up by the polyfill after its loaded.

[calinoracation]

The syncronous snippet might be hard, we can't collect it immediately if say a framework like React mounts or re-renders and that triggers an animation after the snippet but before the polyfill is loaded (or remote stylesheets fetched and parsed). The forwards / both sounds promising. Would that be more effective over calling .play() on the animations when the polyfill initializes?

[flackr]

Would that be more effective over calling .play() on the animations when the polyfill initializes?

Yes! This should avoid any visible side effects. Finished animations will remain finished whereas calling play restarts them.

[flackr]

we can't collect it immediately if say a framework like React mounts or re-renders and that triggers an animation after the snippet but before the polyfill is loaded

This wouldn't be a problem, you'd simply keep a list of animations to check later to see if they should be scroll driven, e.g.

let startedAnimations = new Set();
window.addEventListener('animationstart', (evt) => {
  evt.target.getAnimations().filter(anim => anim.animationName === evt.animationName).forEach(anim => {
    startAnimations.add(anim);
  });
});

Then after the polyfill loads you'd process each of startedAnimations as if they had an animationstart event, i.e. calling the code here: https://github.com/flackr/scroll-timeline/blob/master/src/scroll-timeline-css.js#L174

[calinoracation]

Let me give that a shot!

[calinoracation]

It did seem to work, actually. Was also running into another issue where the syntax parser had invalid syntax so stopped processing all animations. That's probably correct, but challenging in a production scenario.

~@flackr That's not working so well for us either. I guess since we put the 1ms duration for Firefox it's not firing animationstart even instrumented early. I've tried a few other things but nothing is sticking so far.~