flathub-infra / website

Monorepo with website and API
https://flathub.org
Apache License 2.0
191 stars 75 forks source link

“Community built” is sometimes misleading #3055

Open nclm opened 2 weeks ago

nclm commented 2 weeks ago

It seems that Flathub writes:

Community built This app is developed in the open by a community of volunteers, and released under…

for every app that is freely licensed?

I like the intention, but it’s sometimes not really true. For instance https://flathub.org/apps/org.mozilla.firefox is mostly developed by paid Mozilla employees. Many free software projects are not really built by communities of volunteers but by employees of a corporation, even if they accept volunteer contributions. Or by a single benevolent dictator maintainer who does mostly everything alone.

Maybe there should be a toggle in the metadata for each app to activate the “community built” message. In the other case, the block would remain the same, but with a simpler message such as:

Freely licensed This app can be used, shared and modified freely under…

and without the people icon above it. Basically, two different versions of the free software block.