floriankarsten / montagu-slab

Montagu Slab by Florian Karsten

SIL Open Font License 1.1

32 stars 4 forks source link

Browser Preview - Vietnamese 2 #13

Closed vv-monsalve closed 3 years ago

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

Hi @mightybart, I've pulled the latest files in the repo at commit 6440af955df514ddf071d50779aa69400a103874 and these are the new Browser images for Vietnamese.

I've created this new issue to follow up the first one in a cleaner way, as the images tend to be big.

144pt Thin

Results using BrowserStack

Windows 10 Chrome_71 Desktop_Windows_10_chrome_71 0_ Windows 10 Edge_18 Desktop_Windows_10_edge_18 0_ OS X High Sierra Safari_11 Desktop_OS_X_High_Sierra_safari_11 1_

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

To confirm the above results I've asked a friend to open the HTML directly in Windows. Operative system Linux Debian

I'm under the impression that Chrome results are better than in BrowserStack. Some strokes tend to disappear, e.g. the a loop, nevertheless this is the 144pt font.

Chrome Version 88.0.4324.96

Firefox 78

Linux Debian Web Browser vietnamese2-09-144WEBBROWSER

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

16pt Thin

Results using BrowserStack

Windows 10 Chrome_71 Desktop_Windows_10_chrome_71 0_ Windows 10 Edge_18 Desktop_Windows_10_edge_18 0_ OS X High Sierra Safari_11 Desktop_OS_X_High_Sierra_safari_11 1_

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

Results in Windows. Operative system Linux Debian

Chrome Version 88.0.4324.96

Firefox 78

Linux Debian Web Browser vietnamese2-09-16WEBBROWSER

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

Latest Browser images after pulling the files in repo at commit 68ebf273ab873a862be8042a4bffaa5c114d064b

They were created at 18pt to inspect if it would be better to set it as the min malue.

Windows 10 Chrome_71 Desktop_Windows_10_chrome_71 0_ Windows 10 Edge_18 Desktop_Windows_10_edge_18 0_ OS X High Sierra Safari_11 Desktop_OS_X_High_Sierra_safari_11 1_

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

This is a comparison image of the current min 16 value Vs. a 18pt but with a subtle increase in the weight to improve the typographic colour without significantly altering the weight of the font.

Weight Value used for this test was 110.

Montagu-16-18

mightybart commented 3 years ago

I tried to find some values that would work for the 16pt size, and weight: 120 & optical size: -40 gives a nice result. The negative opsz value = lower contrast, increased serif weight. I also tried w: 130, opsz: -35, but I think it's not necessary to go that far.

Frame 1: W: 100 (original) Frame 2: W: 120, OPSZ: -40 Frame 3: W: 130, OPSZ: -35

montagu-16pt

Static sample W: 120, OPSZ: -40

montagu-16pt-120-40

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

Frame 2: W: 120, OPSZ: -40

Looks good. Let me know when you have pushed the new files to run some local tests

mightybart commented 3 years ago

The current version, after extrapolation end cleaning outlines:

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

The current version, after extrapolation end cleaning outlines:

LGTM. I'll pull the latest file in the repo then.

mightybart commented 3 years ago

I pushed the new files as you wrote the comment, so hopefully, we're in sync :)

https://github.com/floriankarsten/montagu-slab/commit/1e36474d5fb1d028b435d31ff9c3ebc0cd3b45f6 this is the last commit that corresponds with the image above

vv-monsalve commented 3 years ago

New images after pulling files at commit 1e36474. They look much better now :D

I think we are ready for the PR 🎉

Windows 10 Chrome_71 Desktop_Windows_10_chrome_71 0_ Windows 10 Edge_18 Desktop_Windows_10_edge_18 0_ OS X High Sierra Safari_11 Desktop_OS_X_High_Sierra_safari_11 1_

davelab6 commented 3 years ago

Looking good!

mightybart commented 3 years ago

Agree ☺️ 👍