Popouts popping out incorrect screen.

FWB800 commented 2 months ago

Aircraft Version

Stable

Build info

{
    "built": "2023-11-03T17:47:36+00:00",
    "ref": "refs/tags/v0.11.1",
    "sha": "f055eb02dc0af32441f8b2873f58e8316d7ca638",
    "actor": "Saschl",
    "event_name": "manual",
    "pretty_release_name": "stable/v0.11.1",
    "version": "v0.11.1-rel.f055eb0"
}

Describe the bug

Whilst popping out pfd and then the nav/flight plan (wasm) screen, the top ecam popped out instead of the nav screen. This was 100% repeatable. I moved across to the copilot side and this side worked OK, but read further. On moving back to the captains side and doing this again, it worked as expected. What I found out was that it is position dependant, when I zoomed in a little and clicked on the pfd then clicked again, this time the mcdu screen displayed. Please see the attached videos.

Expected behavior

I expected the pfd to popout and then the navigation screen to popout as normal. I have tried sending the videos but they are too big, I will try importing them into the ps5 and see if I can edit them there.

Steps to reproduce

ON ground, aircraft ready for take off, clicked on pfd and the rest is as above. I did find it depended on zoom level.

References (optional)

I did try sending the videos but they awere too big, I have now trimmed them down.

https://github.com/flybywiresim/aircraft/assets/158101912/2b5a4929-7c49-418f-80c1-242f1a2510f5

https://github.com/flybywiresim/aircraft/assets/158101912/39ba5668-948c-4296-ac2f-0813fcf9da30

Additional info (optional)

Did nothing special, may have been a problem for a long time but due to the zoom level it been ok.

Discord Username (optional)

SAshton

2hwk commented 2 months ago

I've not been able to reproduce this on the latest development version unfortunately. Maybe others can try.

Pruznak commented 2 months ago

I´ve reproduced this, also on the latest development build. While double clicking on the pfd or nav display from different angles and zoom levels, the upper or lower ecam, the mcdu with different pages (mcdu menu, fuel pred, perf), dcdu or cdu windows popped up along with the pfd popup. It only happend on the captain side though. While double clicking the pfd or nav display on the fo side, only the normal popups actually popped up. I have some videos if needed.

tracernz commented 2 months ago

Double clicking? Popout is Right Alt + Click. Are you using some kind of third-party tool for your popouts?

Pruznak commented 2 months ago

Double clicking? Popout is Right Alt + Click. Are you using some kind of third-party tool for your popouts?

I mean right alt + click and another click right after that while still holding right alt (right alt + double click) I think that´s also what the creator of this issue meant in the first video provided.

SHAshton commented 2 months ago

Hi Pruznak, yes in the 1st video it's a second click on the pfd where the second video if having moved onto the ND.

Pruznak commented 2 months ago

Hello SHAshton, I´ve just tried it again and I can confirm both of those videos, again with the upper or lower ecam and mcdu menu popping up.

SHAshton commented 2 months ago

It's a strange one, with it being if your just at the right distance and the right angle, never seen anything like this before, it's like imagining the cockpit in 3d and your hitting a click point of another screen apart from when I've clicked on the pfd. I was told by one of the guys in FBW discord to report it here. I don't know if the problem has been there for a while, only just this week seen it. I'm finding some popouts frustrating in that they popout minimised.

flybywiresim / aircraft