search

fmof / loglin

http://cs.jhu.edu/~jason/tutorials/loglin/
Other
4 stars 3 forks source link

maybe release some pencil-and-paper questions? #90

Open fmof opened 11 years ago

fmof commented 11 years ago

This is taking your suggestion from the paper and "formalizing" it.

A lot of the practice questions have some feature design component. Releasing some questions might be nice but for feature design the manipulative is one-way (students can't design their own features on-the-fly). The questions could give them good practice, but they wouldn't have a way to verify their answers (without creating their own lesson).

fmof commented 11 years ago

52 might be related.

jeisner commented 11 years ago

To be clear, I was thinking that teachers who give this lesson might want to follow it up with a HW assignment. This could be an "understanding" exercise with pencil and paper, or could involve using MegaM or Vowpal Wabbit or NLTK to build a log-linear model of something.

fmof commented 11 years ago

You mean have a separate "instructor's folder" (analogous to the instructor's key for textbooks)?

jeisner commented 11 years ago

Or perhaps just part of the current pdf folder, though if you are imagining supplying answer keys and stuff, then we have to worry about access control. We don't have time to put anything together tonight but we could note plans or materials in the paper.

I think it's useful for the lesson itself to link to the additional exercises or materials for students, since the lesson might be used by random people not enrolled in any course.

On Thu, Jun 6, 2013 at 11:17 PM, fmof notifications@github.com wrote:

You mean have a separate "instructor's folder" (analogous to the instructor's key for textbooks)?

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/fmof/loglin/issues/90#issuecomment-19086939 .

fmof commented 11 years ago

That's all simple enough to add: I drafted a couple sentences for the intro, but I'm not sure how much to say (or how much to cross-reference those pencil-and-paper questions in section 7 [provided lessons]).

fmof commented 11 years ago

I can only remember two pencil-and-paper questions: the one about cars and the one about politics. IIRC It seems best to release the cars with the bigram model (lesson 16 on the stable, official version) and the politics with logistic regression (lesson 17 on official version). Do we want to release one, both or neither? If so I can quickly update the abstract and appropriate lesson description in the paper.