improve flow of group order when a ordergroup has less than minimum balance

foodcoops / foodsoft

Web-based software to manage a non-profit food coop (product catalog, ordering, accounting, job scheduling).

https://foodcoops.net/

Other

326 stars 146 forks source link

improve flow of group order when a ordergroup has less than minimum balance #1032

Open yksflip opened 11 months ago

yksflip commented 11 months ago

It's pretty confusing for users to complete a group order when their balance is less than the configured minimum balance. Currently all sum table fields turn red and the save button is disabled. It's not understandable what's going on and that you cannot save your order anymore.

I'd suggest:

If your ordergroup has insufficient funds before starting the order, you are not able to edit a grouporder at all, you'll get a warning and get redirected to your grouporder profile where you can see your balance.
If you have enough funds to start a order and order more than your balance, you can still click the save button, but a error modal opens with a explanatory message and you can adapt your order again.
- Another idea would be to save a "draft"-order that are incomplete orders. But I think this would be a much bigger change and open new design questions ...

related: #280

twothreenine commented 8 months ago

If your ordergroup has insufficient funds before starting the order, you are not able to edit a grouporder at all, you'll get a warning and get redirected to your grouporder profile where you can see your balance.

I think you should still be able to view the order and which articles are offered before you decide whether you want to fill up your balance (or by how much). But we could use a warning popup/modal which can be dismissed and/or disable all + buttons of articles with a positive gross price.

If you have enough funds to start a order and order more than your balance, you can still click the save button, but a error modal opens with a explanatory message and you can adapt your order again.

A simple text "insufficient balance" next to the "save" button as soon as you go under the minimum would solve it pretty well, I guess?

also related to #1040

yksflip commented 8 months ago

Yes I understand It would be helpful to actually see what's ordered. I don't like the idea of disabling parts of the form very much, but would be ok if we don't find another solution. I think I'd rather like to present the show view of the grouporder (with a notice) instead of the edit if there's not enough funds?

twothreenine commented 8 months ago

Yes I understand It would be helpful to actually see what's ordered.

That too, but I meant what's offered.

I think I'd rather like to present the show view of the grouporder (with a notice) instead of the edit if there's not enough funds?

Hmm, so that an empty grouporder would be created and then shown? In the show view of the grouporder articles you haven't ordered are hidden by default, so you would need to find the Show/hide articles not ordered button and even then, you couldn't see origin and producer information.