Can't do manual entry - Githubissues

freeotp / freeotp-ios

Apache License 2.0

686 stars 173 forks source link

Can't do manual entry #138

Closed corey851 closed 2 years ago

corey851 commented 4 years ago

Environment: iOS 12.4.4 on iPhone 6. FreeOTP v 1.2 freshly installed from App Store.

Click on plus "+" to do manual entry. I can fill in all the fields but the "Save" button never activates. It remains greyed out and I cannot save the entry.

justin-stephenson commented 4 years ago

Please note in the next release of FreeOTP there will only be QR code scan functionality to add tokens, manual entry will not be possible.

github-account1111 commented 4 years ago

Please note in the next release of FreeOTP there will only be QR code scan functionality to add tokens, manual entry will not be possible.

Why? There are cases where no QR code is available.

Edit: I take my word back. It can be through here: https://freeotp.github.io/qrcode.html

bauen1 commented 4 years ago

Please add this back, maybe a + Icon on the QR code scanner. I don't want to use a website that I would have to audit every time I use it. Sometimes you also get the secret but don't want to use the provided icon / name / issuer. Or your phone doesn't have a working camera.

justin-stephenson commented 4 years ago

Aethedor commented

Please, bring back the add button!! The scan-QR-only makes this app worthless.

9R2by commented 4 years ago

is there a specific reason, why these buttons were removed ?

adam820 commented 4 years ago

It's a little disappointing to see that this feature has been ripped out, without any indication for the reasoning why. As multiple people have stated, I have a need for OTP in an environment whereby I can neither click the URI or scan the QR code. This change essentially renders this application useless for such an environment.

I can understand trying to simplify the UI and make things easy for the end-user, but for those of us who need the advanced features, it would be nice to still be able to access them.

RamonvdW commented 2 years ago

A bit frustrated with FreeOTP and the need to add many manual entries (migrating to new phone) I decided to create a solution. It runs locally, so no need to send your secrets to a website: https://github.com/RamonvdW/qr-code Enjoy!

igor2890 commented 2 years ago

Created new manual entry screen with functionality
Not supported token lock setting and icons (right now)
Need help to test and improve

igor2890 commented 2 years ago

Now I think not to make changes to the Token and OTP classes, make a data translator class in URLC and use standard class methods. Some more time is needed.