search

fsfe / reuse-tool

reuse is a tool for compliance with the REUSE recommendations.
https://reuse.software
399 stars 148 forks source link

Please allow for a hidden REUSE.toml file #1054

Closed mlramd closed 3 months ago

mlramd commented 3 months ago

I like the idea of using reuse to check my projects, but I don't want the REUSE.toml file in the root directory. It seems like an advertisement for the reuse project. For now I'm just going to keep local copies of the file instead of committing it to the repo.

Could you make reuse work with .REUSE.toml or .reuse/REUSE.toml please? Even giving reuse an option for a config file name, rather than having it hardcoded would work.

Thanks.

carmenbianca commented 3 months ago

Hi @mlramd, I am closing this WONTFIX. From #779:

I intend to support exclusively REUSE.toml, and NOT .REUSE.toml. People will be peeved by this choice (they don't like random tools littering their clean workspace), but I propose that we stand by this choice. By allowing dotfiles, we would run the risk that the licensing information is hidden on some computers. Licensing information should not be hidden, ergo let's not do dotfiles.

The importance here is the visibility of licensing.

We could have gone with an 'unbranded' LICENSING.toml, but the whole REUSE endeavour is non-profit run by a charity, so the self-propagation via the name of the file is fine to me.

seabass-labrax commented 3 months ago

In my experience, a sizeable proportion of those who do FOSS licence compliance have a legal background, and not always a technical one. Having the files hidden by default would add an impediment (admittedly, a small one) to their task. Given that the primary reason for REUSE is to make licence compliance easier, I don't personally think it's the right trade-off to make.

mlramd commented 3 months ago

If you want to force this on people, I can understand that, but I'm not going to be checking the REUSE.toml file into my projects, and I imagine that there will be others that agree.

In my mind, reuse is a tool to make sure that we have the licensing in the project correct, and honestly that's all it is. If the licensing isn't correct unless there's an advertisement for your tool in the root of the project, I think that's a problem.

Regardless, your projects choices are up to you - All I can say is that I'm not going to be forced into having the file at the root of my projects.

Take care. Martin