search

fsolt / dcpo_gender_roles

Comparable, cross-national time-series estimates of public opinion toward egalitarian gender roles
2 stars 0 forks source link

Good Comments from Reviewers (For Memo) #24

Closed byngdeuk closed 2 years ago

byngdeuk commented 3 years ago

Reviewer #1

  1. The manuscript is well written and the issue that they seek to address is clearly defined. It is strongly situated on existing scholarship on the topic, which is of broad significance, and it follows a number of other projects that are using latent variable modeling to improve measures in comparative politics. The dataset that they describe may be of interest to a more specific audience, but this seems an appropriate venue for its introduction.

Reviewer #2

  1. I think this is a good paper and I look forward to seeing it in print. I am unlikely to use their measure in my research (because I rarely do cross-national work) but I envision assigning this article to my students as an excellent example of a measurement paper (for undergrads) and an IRT model (for my grad students).
  2. In sum, I think this is a great measure and an impressive paper. I have some qualms with the writing itself, which I think can be simplified and explained more and which I have explained above, but otherwise I support accepting this paper.
byngdeuk commented 2 years ago

Related to the revised version of draft and appendix, I like the way it is organized and reacted to the comments Fred!

fsolt commented 2 years ago

Okay, @byngdeuk, I think it's ready to go. Please check dcpo_gender_roles.pdf (which, astoundingly, is at just 3934 words), pge_appendix.pdf, and response_memo.pdf and let me know your thoughts.

byngdeuk commented 2 years ago

Dear Fred,

I read the documents over and I totally agree with that we handle the reviewer's comments on our previous manuscript! I'm really happy to our revised manuscript and I think it is ready to be resubmited:)!

Thanks!!

All My Best, -Byung-Deuk.