search

fsolt / dcpo_gender_roles

Comparable, cross-national time-series estimates of public opinion toward egalitarian gender roles
2 stars 0 forks source link

Explanation about Surveys Employed in Our Paper #25

Closed byngdeuk closed 2 years ago

byngdeuk commented 3 years ago

Reviewer #1

  1. Though the Appendix (A) explains dispersion and difficulty, they should include some discussion or representation in the main text. One illustrative example is Figure 1 in Gandhi and Sumner (2020, "Measuring the Consolidation of Power in Nondemocracies"). The note should also consider adding more description about how the estimates were obtained (e.g., section 4.3 and 4.4 of Claassen 2018 or final paragraph before "Results" of Gandhi and Sumner 2020).

Reviewer #2

  1. Finally, a small but important point: It isn't entirely clear from the paper whether you are only using cross-national surveys or whether you also incorporate single-country surveys? (I'm mostly confused because of sentences such as "Country coverage reached its peak in 2008, when surveys in 78 countries included items on gender egalitarianism in the public sphere")
fsolt commented 2 years ago

R2: We clarified that we are drawing on both cross-national and single-country surveys at the top of page 2. We also revised the sentence on peak country coverage in an attempt to avoid any confusion. c698e994855fd415d7a169efef3c9684d9c1b879

fsolt commented 2 years ago

R1's two points here really aren't related to each other or R2's point, so I split them off (see #30 and #31) and close this one, @byngdeuk.