search

fvwmorg / fvwm3

FVWM version 3 -- the successor to fvwm2
Other
505 stars 79 forks source link

StartsOnPage/StartsOnDesk ignored #39

Closed afhp-2020 closed 4 years ago

afhp-2020 commented 4 years ago

Hello,

Using a config file I am adapting and correcting from fvwm2, I came across a regression regarding forced window placement on a given desktop. Configuration is explicitely declared global (but it makes no difference) : DesktopConfiguration global

I do not use pages, and 4 desktops are defined:

DesktopSize 1x1
DesktopName 0 Net
DesktopName 1 Dev
DesktopName 2 MM
DesktopName 3 Misc
EdgeScroll 0 0
EdgeThickness 0

Multimedia applications are set to open on Desktop 2:

Style vlc StartsOnPage 2
Style mpv StartsOnPage 2

(StartsOnDesk 2 does no better)

Opening any application defined as above to open on a given desk results in the application actually opening on the current active desk.

This configuration was working as expected under fvwm2.

It should be noted that StartsOnScreen on the other hand works as documented.

ThomasAdam commented 4 years ago

Hi,

Yes, you're right. Probably related to #22.

ThomasAdam commented 4 years ago

Can you retest this, please? I've tested this with:

Style xeyes StartsOnScreen HDMI2, StartsOnPage 1 1, SkipMapping

... and starting xeyes: xeyes +shape puts that window on Page 1 1, on my second screen (which is not considered the active screen; that is, my mouse pointer is on a different monitor) -- so this is working OK.

You should build fvwm3 on the ta/gh-22 branch.

Please confirm.

afhp-2020 commented 4 years ago

Hello,

Not yet entirely familiar with git ; did a git pull origin ta/gh-22, recompiled, reinstalled and restarted from display manager. (Note: compiling and installing with make ; sudo make install on FreeBSD, compiles and installs without error. Thanks for keeping the code system- and make-agnostic.)

Testing with current configuration elements, as in Style mpv StartsOnPage 2, as well as variations on your style definition above, in succession:

Style xeyes StartsOnScreen DP-2, StartsOnDesk <n> : as before, Screen is respected, Desk is ignored, the window appears on the current desk. Same with StartOnPage <n>.

Since I am not using pages, StartsOnPage with non-zero 2nd and/or 3rd argument obviously cause the window to not be shown. Otherwise, same behavior, the window appears on the current desk regardless of the first argument.

The presence or absence of SkipMapping has no effect.

ThomasAdam commented 4 years ago

Hi @afhp-2020

Really fixed this time. Please git pull on ta/gh-22 as you've been doing and try again!

This is working for me:

Style xeyes StartsOnDesk 4

afhp-2020 commented 4 years ago

Got lost in git merge so I re-cloned master and re-pulled ta/gh-22 again.

I am happy to report that the issue is fixed.

Style xeyes StartsOnDesk <n> issued at FvwmConsole, starting xeyes opens it on the specified desktop. Similarly with existing Style <application> StartsOnPage 2 in config file, specified applications open where expected.