search

fxe025 / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

Unexpected graduate output when failing a module #2

Open fxe025 opened 2 months ago

fxe025 commented 2 months ago

I edit my module cs2113 grade to be F

_____________________________________________________________
view
_____________________________________________________________
CEG Study Plan for: Fu Xueer
_____________________________________________________________
| Y1S1 [Sem 1] | Y1S2 [Sem 2] | Y2S1 [Sem 3] | Y2S2 [Sem 4] |
|              |              |              |CS2113      F |
_____________________________________________________________
| Y3S1 [Sem 5] | Y3S2 [Sem 6] | Y4S1 [Sem 7] | Y4S2 [Sem 8] |
_____________________________________________________________
- Current Study: Semester 8
- Total MCs taken: 4.00 / 160
- Total MCs listed: 4.00 / 160
_____________________________________________________________

By right I should retake this module but graduate command won't return cs2113

+---------------------------+------------+
| Course Code               | MCs        |
+---------------------------+------------+
| ES2631                    | 4          |
| CS1010                    | 4          |
| GEA1000                   | 4          |
| DTK1234                   | 4          |
| EG1311                    | 4          |
| IE2141                    | 4          |
| EE2211                    | 4          |
| CDE2501                   | 4          |
| CDE2000                   | 4          |
| PF1101                    | 4          |
| CG4002                    | 8          |
| MA1511                    | 2          |
| MA1512                    | 2          |
| MA1508E                   | 4          |
| EG2401A                   | 2          |
| EG3611A                   | 10         |
| CP3880                    | 12         |
| CG1111A                   | 4          |
| CG2111A                   | 4          |
| CS1231                    | 4          |
| CG2023                    | 4          |
| CG2027                    | 2          |
| CG2028                    | 2          |
| CG2271                    | 4          |
| CS2040C                   | 4          |
| EE2026                    | 4          |
| EE4204                    | 4          |
+---------------------------+------------+
nus-se-script commented 2 months ago

Team's Response

While we agree that it is a functionality not supported in the current iteration of the product, it should be a type.FeatureFlaw instead of a type.FunctionalityBug as its behaviour is expected. We argue that it leans more towards "functionality missing from a feature", hence a type.FeatureFlaw.

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue type

Team chose [type.FeatureFlaw] Originally [type.FunctionalityBug]

Reason for disagreement: [replace this with your explanation]