g4klx / MMDVMHost

The host program for the MMDVM
GNU General Public License v2.0
379 stars 274 forks source link

DR-1X repeater won't repeat MMDVM setup as Remote Gateway #430

Closed WO1VES closed 6 years ago

WO1VES commented 6 years ago

Greetings All,

I am trying to setup an MMDVM as a remote gateway to a Yaesu DR-1X repeater that doesn't have Internet access at the site. I am setting it up as for System Fusion on both YSF reflectors and FCS reflectors, and I set the option for "RemoteGateway" in the MMDVM.ini file to "1" but the DR-1X won't repeat anything transmitted from the MMDVM. Instead, it sees the MMDVM as another repeater and transmits the digital noise in analog mode.

Transmissions from the repeater, to the MMDVM, come through just fine if receiving on another MMDVM or hotspot to a handheld. But fails on any repeater.

Is there any way of getting the MMDVM to behave like a Wires-X Gateway? Right now the MMDVM is acting like another repeater, but should act like a gateway.

Thanks!

WO1VES

iu7igu commented 6 years ago

Hi WO1VES, the DR-1X repeater can't repeat MMDVM's transmission because MMDVMHost software send data like repeater and yaesu repeater see this like another repeater and don't work. I hope that this problem will be solved because i need to use a system like your.

Skinoku commented 6 years ago

Hi! I am also trying that to link two rooms and found out that it doesn't work. It should be running like a regular YSF radio sending just the callsign and the GPS data, not also the repeater of origin otherwise the DR-1X will think he is on the same freq with other repeaters and won't repeat avoiding a endless loop. Any idea how to fix or tell if I can contribute? Thanks a lot IU1INZ

juribeparada commented 6 years ago

Hi, can you test from my repo?: https://github.com/juribeparada/MMDVMHost

I am trying to figure out this issue, but I don't have any access to a DR-1X.

Andy CA6JAU.

Skinoku commented 6 years ago

Dear Andy, Now I'm away so unable to experiment. But I tell a way you can figure out yourself without a DR1. You still need a c4fm radio, of course. The ft1d for example on the display shows when talking on a repeater CALLSING R>REPEATERCALL Continuously alternating For mmdvm it should show on the display just the callsign of the person speaking and nothing else except the gps distance. To make it even simpler, it should behave like you are taking SIMPLEX with another c4fm radio, otherwise loop protection of the DR1 will engage and won't repeat the mmdvm. The SHARK version of hotspot will do exactly what I described and it works well.

73s IU1INZ Lorenzo

juribeparada commented 6 years ago

OK, thanks for you information, but I still need that you or somebody else confirm the change that I did. Then I will continue investigating depending of my free time. Regards.

WO1VES commented 6 years ago

Hi Andy,

I've been running the Pi-Star release, so I will have to figure out how to compile myself. I'll figure it out, and give your build a try. Thanks for looking into this.

Brian - WO1VES

juribeparada commented 6 years ago

Any news on this?, have anyone tested my changes from my repository?. I will not put any change to the official MMDVMHost until some confirmation.

mreckhof commented 6 years ago

Just saw this and may be what's causing a problem for me. Let me pull this repo and test.

juribeparada commented 6 years ago

mreckhof: remember to test this repo: https://github.com/juribeparada/MMDVMHost

mreckhof commented 6 years ago

I’ve only been able to do limited testing so far, but it appears to be working for me. My setup is:

HT Radio —> MMDVM Hotspot —> YSFReflector —> MMDVM RF Bridge (duplex hat) —> DR1-X —> HT Radio

Without the patch I was getting digital noise over audio. With the patch, I’m getting proper digital communication.

I’ve also had to set low deviation and using remotegateway=1.

I’ll do more testing over the next few days as I find the time, but so far, it’s working at least for how I need it to!

Thanks!

juribeparada commented 6 years ago

OK, good news that the patch works, I will add to this oficial repo soon.

juribeparada commented 6 years ago

Now it is added to the oficial repo

mreckhof commented 6 years ago

Thank you, for all you do for the ham community!