[Paladin] Beacon of Light applies the original heal's modifiers to the beacon heal

gamefreedomgit / Frostmourne

3 stars 1 forks source link

[Paladin] Beacon of Light applies the original heal's modifiers to the beacon heal #1645

Closed oomshroom closed 1 week ago

oomshroom commented 3 weeks ago

The duplicated heal from Beacon of Light includes healing modifiers to the target of the original heal (say, Holy Light).

Example:

assume a normal Holy Light heals for 10k
place Beacon of Light on unit A, which has no modifiers to healing taken
cast Holy Light on unit B, which has 40% increased healing taken
unit A gets healed by beacon for 14k instead of 10k

This can easily be abused in raids with a Hunter tenacity pet, Warlock Demon Armor, etc.

comment about wotlk 3.3.5 comment about wotlk classic

reminuz commented 3 weeks ago

Same thing with mortal strike in arena. If i heal a target with mortal strike, beacon should receive 100% healing, not 50%. For example yesterday i was vs double war in arena. I used beacon on my party2 and I healed party 1. Both of them had mortal strike reduction. Party 1 received 50% heals and party2 received 25%, because of double mortal strike. They should received both 50% healer.

Piootrek commented 2 weeks ago

I need more information on how it should exactly work. Should heal from the beacon benefit from positive/negative healing modifiers? So in your example if target A had a Demon Armor would he receive 20% more healing from beacon? Blizzard spell attributes say that beacon shouldn't benefit from positive auras at all, that's why I need proofs.

oomshroom commented 2 weeks ago

In the example you provided, target A with Demon Armor SHOULD receive 20% more healing from beacon.

Proof from wotlk classic: https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/TZN7kKHnV9c2BFm8#fight=5&type=summary&view=events&pins=2%24Off%24%23244F4B%24expression%24ability.name%3D%22Beacon%20of%20Light%22%5E2%24Off%24%23909049%24expression%24ability.name%3D%22Vampiric%20Blood%22 When Vampiric Blood is used, beacon heals clearly become 35% larger (21k->28k or so)

Proof from wotlk 3.3.5: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nt8ZUyVDqYc at around 3:07 you can see him use Vampiric Blood, and the beacon heals from crit holy lights become ~27k when they were previously ~20k.

Rowern96 commented 2 weeks ago

as far as i understand it, the spell is copied on the beacon target but the heal amount is calculated seperatly on both targets depending on their buffs and debuffs

reminuz commented 2 weeks ago

https://youtu.be/8HnEhpwDdEI?si=rdRDfm-t6RZ-Id49 min 42.50 U can see 2.6k healing on war with mortal strike and 5.2k on paladin with beacon

reminuz commented 1 week ago

Piootrek commented 1 week ago

Fixed