gammapy / gamma-cat

An open data collection and source catalog for gamma-ray astronomy
https://gamma-cat.readthedocs.io/
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
15 stars 17 forks source link

Add VERITAS IC 443 2015arXiv151201911H #98

Closed cdeil closed 6 years ago

cdeil commented 7 years ago
cdeil commented 7 years ago

@GernotMaier - Can you get your hands on the spectral points for IC 443 from http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2015ICRC...34..875H ?

cdeil commented 7 years ago

After #140 I re-ran the scripts to update the auto-generated files and made a few more small fixes in master.

There's one remaining problem I see here: https://github.com/cdeil/gamma-cat-status/commit/d9da0e138502805068eca039047936eccebf99bd#diff-ae36e7e6fccd700ddf695565bb971cff

The spectral points from input/data/2009/2009ApJ...698L.133A/tev-000029-sed.ecsv are all below the spectral model from input/data/2009/2009ApJ...698L.133A/tev-000029.yaml. Looking at the numbers from the paper to me the spectral model parameters seem correct: http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0004-637X/698/2/L133/meta#apjl315544s3 @GernotMaier - Can you please have a look and try to fix this?

Also, the spectral model from input/data/2015/2015arXiv151201911H/tev-000029.yaml seems very different / inconsistent with the spectral model from 2009ApJ...698L.133A. Another data entry bug?

cdeil commented 6 years ago

Update: I think there is still an issue with the spectra for this source. See https://github.com/cdeil/gamma-cat-status/blob/cc3084fc9b43933a93203275eed7385d322efb82/notebooks/data_collection_example.ipynb .

GernotMaier commented 6 years ago

Checked this and found out that the normalisation energy in the proceedings is very likely wrong: e_ref should be 1 TeV, and not 550 GeV .

I leave this issue open until I get confirmation from the corresponding author.

GernotMaier commented 6 years ago

Close this now - received confirmation that the normalisation energy is 1 TeV and fixed this in the yaml file.

cdeil commented 6 years ago

Fixed by @GernotMaier in #209.