Comments from Marianne Lemoine-Goumard

gammapy / gammapy-v1.0-paper

Repository for the Gammapy v1.0 paper

6 stars 17 forks source link

Closed bkhelifi closed 1 year ago

bkhelifi commented 1 year ago

Very nice and complete paper! Congrats...

Some possible typos:
- l115: n => on
- l763: "with by" => "with"
Some questions
- About fig 4 on the LAT PSF: the used one seems worse than the one published in the LAT collaboration (https://www.slac.stanford.edu/exp/glast/groups/canda/lat_Performance_files/gPsfAve68Energy_P8R3_SOURCE_V3psf_10MeV.png). From the LAT, the 68% PSF is about 0.11° at 10 GeV, and in this figure it seems that it is 0.15° at 10 GeV.. Can you check again this quantity?

adonath commented 1 year ago

l115: n => on l763: "with by" => "with"

Both were found by other previous reviews, fixed.

adonath commented 1 year ago

The remaining comment on Fig 1 I'll add to #124.