gardener-attic / component-spec

component descriptor specification and language bindings
2 stars 15 forks source link

Referenced url not found #81

Open nab-gha opened 2 years ago

nab-gha commented 2 years ago

What happened: Tried to access url at https://github.com/gardener/component-spec/blob/master/language-independent/component-descriptor-v2-schema.yaml#L1 but got 404

What you expected to happen: Return a document describing yaml How to reproduce it (as minimally and precisely as possible): cut and paste url https://gardener.cloud/schemas/component-descriptor-v2 to browser.

Anything else we need to know: Same reference at https://github.com/gardener/component-spec/blob/master/doc/proposal/component-descriptor-v2-schema.yaml#L1 Environment:

nab-gha commented 2 years ago

Now reading the README.md again, these files relate the the existing CNUDIE and not OCM specification so this is not an OCM issue. Should we separate the OCM specification documentation and artefacts into a separate repository to avoid confusion and allow us to develop the new OCM specification documentation and examples ready for wider publication.

In-Ko commented 2 years ago

I think it is a good idea to clearly separate the two (CNUDIE and OCM) specifications / documentations and artifacts. Should we have a repo like "gardener/ocm-spec" or similar ? Or simply move everything now under the existing "gardener/ocm" repo (internally structured via folders for example), as we will move to the "real OCM home" anyhow at a later point in time ?

nab-gha commented 2 years ago

I'd support gardener/ocm-spec which might one day become ocm/spec, I think moving it into the existing gardener/ocm would be ok but better to have a separate repo for the spec and the cli.

In-Ko commented 2 years ago

ok, so we go for a separate gardener/ocm-spec repo, will also make it easier later on to move all those "ocm" repos under a new org. So then we should:

I am aware of at least one PR that still needs to find its way to the proposal spec in this repo ("component-spec"), so we have to wait until this is done, and then we can do the move.