search

gardener / gardener-extension-provider-aws

Gardener extension controller for the AWS cloud provider (https://aws.amazon.com).
https://gardener.cloud
Apache License 2.0
18 stars 96 forks source link

Update ETCD volume to lower storage capacity #646

Open shreyas-s-rao opened 1 year ago

shreyas-s-rao commented 1 year ago

How to categorize this issue?

/area backup /area storage /area cost /kind enhancement /platform aws

What would you like to be added: Update ETCD volume (GP3) to use lower storage capacity.

Why is this needed: The current storage capacity of 80Gi was used for GP2 volumes for ETCD data storage, since the IOPS for GP2 volumes is determined by the volume size. Hence, 80Gi was set as the volume size in order to achieve optimum IOPS for ETCD, even though the ETCD DB and additional operations do not utilise the entire 80GB of storage. With the move to GP3 volumes, this is no longer necessary - the storage capacity can be reduced to a lower value sufficient enough to host the ETCD DB and allow additional operations on it (such as defragmentation, restoration, etc).

shreyas-s-rao commented 1 year ago

/assign

unmarshall commented 1 year ago

@shreyas-s-rao as you have already found out that just by changing the storageCapacity a statefulset cannot be updated. If one tries to do that the following error will be returned:

The StatefulSet "web" is invalid: spec: Forbidden: updates to statefulset spec for fields other than 'replicas', 'template', 'updateStrategy', 'persistentVolumeClaimRetentionPolicy' and 'minReadySeconds' are forbidden

For a multi-node etcd if you wish to avoid down time and also change the storageCapacity to a lower capacity then there is one way to do it:

  1. Change the update strategy from RollingUpdate to OnDelete for the statefulset.
  2. Delete the Statefulset with --cascade=orphan so that it does not delete the pods.
  3. Update the statefulset with the reduced storageCapacity (25Gi) and recreate the statefulset.
  4. The pods will continue to use the PVC which requested 80Gi of space.
  5. Delete one pod and also ensure that its PVC is deleted. For a multi-node etcd you will still retain the quorum. Since the update strategy has changed you will see a new pod with a new PVC with 25Gi of storage capacity. The remainder of the pods will not be udpated.

Repeat this for all the pods and this way you would be able to update all etc statefulset replicas while maintaining quorum. Since you have control over the update process, you can wait till the new etcd member has been promoted to a member.

unmarshall commented 1 year ago

We anyways should change the update strategy from RollingUpdate to OnDelete to ensure that quorum is always maintained which is not possible to ensure when using RollingUpdate