gbv / jskos-data

Collection of knowledge organization systems encoded in JSKOS format
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
8 stars 4 forks source link

dfg wrong hierarchy #23

Closed andrecastro0o closed 2 years ago

andrecastro0o commented 2 years ago

@nichtich Is perhaps the dfg/dfg-2020.concepts.csv hierarchy incorrect?

As I was going over it in https://github.com/tibonto/DFG-Fachsystematik-Ontology/issues/1 I realized what I thought was the case, that the CSV was ordered hierarchically for level 0,1,2 where the hierarchical subsumption would by a parent being following by its direct children, is not the case

For instance

I would like to know if this is a bug or not. And if not, how can it be inferred that 11 is a child of 1; and 101 a child of 101?

I am basing the hierarchy on https://www.dfg.de/download/pdf/dfg_im_profil/gremien/fachkollegien/amtsperiode_2020_2024/fachsystematik_2020-2024_en_grafik.pdf

andrecastro0o commented 2 years ago

Here is a overview of the hierarchy + current order from the CSV created with

import csv

with open('dfg-2020.concepts.csv', newline='') as csvfile:
    csvfile = csv.DictReader(csvfile, delimiter=',')
    for i, row in enumerate(csvfile):
        # print(row)
        print(f"{'-' * (int(row['level']) * 4)}* L{row['level']}  {row['notation']} {row['prefLabel@en']}") #  
* L0  1 Humanities and Social Sciences
        * L2  101 Ancient Cultures
        * L2  102 History
        * L2  103 Art History, Music, Theatre and Media Studies
        * L2  104 Linguistics
        * L2  105 Literary Studies
        * L2  106 Social and Cultural Anthropology, Non-European Cultures, Jewish Studies and Religious Studies
        * L2  107 Theology
        * L2  108 Philosophy
        * L2  109 Educational Research
        * L2  110 Psychology
        * L2  111 Social Sciences
        * L2  112 Economics
        * L2  113 Jurisprudence
    * L1  11 Humanities
    * L1  12 Social and Behavioural Sciences
        * L2  201 Basic Research in Biology and Medicine
        * L2  202 Plant Sciences
        * L2  203 Zoology
        * L2  204 Microbiology, Virology and Immunology
        * L2  205 Medicine
        * L2  206 Neurosciences
        * L2  207 Agriculture, Forestry and Veterinary Medicine
    * L1  21 Biology
    * L1  22 Medicine
    * L1  23 Agriculture, Forestry and Veterinary Medicine
* L0  2 Life Sciences
        * L2  307 Condensed Matter Physics
        * L2  308 Optics, Quantum Optics and Physics of Atoms, Molecules and Plasmas
        * L2  309 Particles, Nuclei and Fields
        * L2  310 Statistical Physics, Soft Matter, Biological Physics, Nonlinear Dynamics
        * L2  311 Astrophysics and Astronomy
        * L2  312 Mathematics
        * L2  313 Atmospheric Science, Oceanography and Climate Research
        * L2  314 Geology and Palaeontology
        * L2  315 Geophysics and Geodesy
        * L2  316 Mineralogy, Petrology and Geochemistry
        * L2  317 Geography
        * L2  318 Water Research
    * L1  31 Chemistry
        * L2  321 Molecular Chemistry
        * L2  322 Chemical Solid State and Surface Research
        * L2  323 Physical Chemistry
        * L2  324 Analytical Chemistry
        * L2  325 Biological Chemistry and Food Chemistry
        * L2  326 Polymer Research
        * L2  327 Theoretical Chemistry
    * L1  32 Physics
    * L1  33 Mathematics
    * L1  34 Geosciences 
* L0  3 Natural Sciences
        * L2  401 Production Technology
        * L2  402 Mechanics and Constructive Mechanical Engineering
        * L2  403 Process Engineering, Technical Chemistry
        * L2  404 Fluid Mechanics, Technical Thermodynamics and Thermal Energy Engineering
        * L2  405 Materials Engineering
        * L2  406 Materials Science
        * L2  407 Systems Engineering
        * L2  408 Electrical Engineering and Information Technology
        * L2  409 Computer Science
        * L2  410 Construction Engineering and Architecture
    * L1  41 Mechanical and Industrial Engineering
    * L1  42 Thermal Engineering/ Process Engineering
    * L1  43 Materials Science and Engineering
    * L1  44 Computer Science, Systems and  Electrical Engineering
    * L1  45 Construction Engineering and Architecture
* L0  4 Engineering Sciences
            * L3  101-01 Prehistory and World Archaeology
            * L3  101-02 Classical Philology
            * L3  101-03 Ancient History
            * L3  101-04 Classical Archaeology
            * L3  101-05 Egyptology and Ancient Near Eastern Studies
            * L3  102-01 Medieval History
            * L3  102-02 Early Modern History
            * L3  102-03 Modern and Current History
            * L3  102-04 History of Science
            * L3  103-01 Art History
            * L3  103-02 Musicology
            * L3  103-03 Theatre and Media Studies
            * L3  104-01 General and Comparative Linguistics, Typology, Non-European Languages
            * L3  104-02 Individual Linguistics
            * L3  104-03 Historical Linguistics
            * L3  104-04 Applied Linguistics, Experimental Linguistics, Computational Linguistics
            * L3  105-01 Medieval German Literature
            * L3  105-02 Modern German Literature
            * L3  105-03 European and American Literature
            * L3  105-04 General and Comparative Literature and Cultural Studies
            * L3  106-01 Social and Cultural Anthropology and Ethnology 
            * L3  106-02 Asian Studies
            * L3  106-03 African, American and Oceania Studies 
            * L3  106-04 Islamic Studies, Arabian Studies, Semitic Studies
            * L3  106-05 Religious Studies and Jewish Studies
            * L3  107-01 Protestant Theology
            * L3  107-02 Roman Catholic Theology
            * L3  108-01 History of Philosophy
            * L3  108-02 Theoretical Philosophy
            * L3  108-03 Practical Philosophy
            * L3  109-01 General Education and History of Education
            * L3  109-02 General and Domain-Specific Teaching and Learning
            * L3  109-03 Education Systems and Educational Institutions
            * L3  109-04 Educational Research on Socialisation, Welfare and Professionalism Research
            * L3  110-01 General, Cognitive and Mathematical Psychology
            * L3  110-02 Biological Psychology and Cognitive Neuroscience
            * L3  110-03 Developmental and Educational Psychology
            * L3  110-04 Social Psychology, Industrial and Organisational Psychology
            * L3  110-05 Differential, Clinical and Medical Psychology, Methodology
            * L3  111-01 Sociological Theory
            * L3  111-02 Empirical Social Research
            * L3  111-03 Communication Sciences
            * L3  111-04 Political Science
            * L3  112-01 Economic Theory
            * L3  112-02 Economic Policy, Applied Economics
            * L3  112-03 Business Administration
            * L3  112-04 Statistics and Econometrics
            * L3  112-05 Economic and Social History
            * L3  113-01 Principles of Law and Jurisprudence
            * L3  113-02 Private Law
            * L3  113-03 Public Law
            * L3  113-04 Criminal Law
            * L3  113-05 Criminology
            * L3  201-01 Biochemistry
            * L3  201-02 Biophysics
            * L3  201-03 Cell Biology
            * L3  201-04 Structural Biology
            * L3  201-05 General Genetics and Functional Genome Biology
            * L3  201-06 Developmental Biology
            * L3  201-07 Bioinformatics and Theoretical Biology
            * L3  202-01 Evolution and Systematics of Plants and Fungi
            * L3  202-02 Ecology and Biodiversity of Plants and Ecosystems
            * L3  202-03 Organismic Interactions, Chemical Ecology and Microbiomes of Plant Systems
            * L3  202-04 Plant Physiology
            * L3  202-05 Plant Biochemistry and Biophysics
            * L3  202-06 Plant Cell and Developmental Biology
            * L3  202-07 Plant Genetics
            * L3  203-01 Systematics and Morphology (Zoology)
            * L3  203-02 Evolution, Anthropology
            * L3  203-03 Ecology and Biodiversity of Animals and Ecosystems, Organismic Interactions
            * L3  203-04 Sensory and Behavioural Biology
            * L3  203-05 Animal Physiology and Biochemistry
            * L3  203-06 Evolutionary Cell and Developmental Biology (Zoology)
            * L3  204-01 Metabolism, Biochemistry and Genetics of Microorganisms
            * L3  204-02 Microbial Ecology and Applied Microbiology
            * L3  204-03 Medical Microbiology and Mycology, Hygiene, Molecular Infection Biology
            * L3  204-04 Virology
            * L3  204-05 Immunology
            * L3  204-06 Parasitology and Biology of Tropical Infectious Disease Pathogens
            * L3  205-01 Epidemiology and Medical Biometry/Statistics
            * L3  205-02 Public Health, Health Services Research, Social Medicine
            * L3  205-03 Human Genetics
            * L3  205-04 Physiology
            * L3  205-05 Nutritional Sciences
            * L3  205-06 Pathology
            * L3  205-07 Medical Informatics and Medical Bioinformatics
            * L3  205-08 Pharmacy
            * L3  205-09 Pharmacology
            * L3  205-10 Toxicology, Occupational Medicine, Clinical Chemistry
            * L3  205-11 Anaesthesiology
            * L3  205-12 Cardiology, Angiology
            * L3  205-13 Pneumology, Thoracic Surgery
            * L3  205-14 Hematology, Oncology
            * L3  205-15 Gastroenterology
            * L3  205-16 Nephrology
            * L3  205-17 Endocrinology, Diabetology, Metabolism
            * L3  205-18 Rheumatology
            * L3  205-19 Dermatology
            * L3  205-20 Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine
            * L3  205-21 Gynaecology and Obstetrics
            * L3  205-22 Clinical Immunology and Allergology
            * L3  205-23 Reproductive Medicine, Urology
            * L3  205-24 Biogerontology and Geriatric Medicine
            * L3  205-25 General and Visceral Surgery
            * L3  205-26 Cardiac and Vascular Sugery
            * L3  205-27 Orthopaedics, Traumatology, Reconstructive Surgery
            * L3  205-28 Dentistry, Oral Surgery
            * L3  205-29 Otolaryngology
            * L3  205-30 Radiology, Nuclear Medicine, Radiotherapy, Radiobiology
            * L3  205-31 Clinical Infectiology and Tropical Medicine
            * L3  205-32 Medical Physics, Biomedical Technology
            * L3  205-33 Anatomy
            * L3  206-01 Developmental Neurobiology
            * L3  206-02 Molecular Biology and Physiology of Neurons and Glial Cells
            * L3  206-03 Experimental and Theoretical Network Neuroscience
            * L3  206-04 Cognitive, Systems and Behavioural Neurobiology
            * L3  206-05 Experimental Models for the Understanding of Nervous System Diseases
            * L3  206-06 Molecular and Cellular Neurology and Neuropathology
            * L3  206-07 Clinical Neurosciences; Neurosurgery und Neuroradiology
            * L3  206-08 Human Cognitive and Systems Neuroscience
            * L3  206-09 Biological Psychiatry
            * L3  206-10 Clinical Psychiatry, Psychotherapy, Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
            * L3  206-11 Ophthalmology
            * L3  207-01 Soil Sciences
            * L3  207-02 Plant Breeding and Plant Pathology
            * L3  207-03 Plant Cultivation, Plant Nutrition, Agricultural Technology
            * L3  207-04 Ecology of Land Use
            * L3  207-05 Agricultural Economics, Agricultural Policy, Agricultural Sociology
            * L3  207-06 Forestry
            * L3  207-07 Animal Breeding, Animal Nutrition, Animal Husbandry
            * L3  207-08 Veterinary Medical Science
            * L3  321-01 Inorganic Molecular Chemistry - Synthesis and Characterisation
            * L3  321-02 Organic Molecular Chemistry - Synthesis and Characterisation
            * L3  322-01 Solid State and Surface Chemistry, Material Synthesis
            * L3  322-02 Physical Chemistry of Solids and Surfaces, Material Characterisation
            * L3  323-01 Physical Chemistry of Molecules, Liquids and Interfaces, Biophysical Chemistry
            * L3  324-01 Analytical Chemistry
            * L3  325-01 Biological and Biomimetic Chemistry
            * L3  325-02 Food Chemistry
            * L3  326-01 Preparatory and Physical Chemistry of Polymers
            * L3  326-02 Experimental and Theoretical Physics of Polymers
            * L3  326-03 Polymer Materials
            * L3  327-01 Electron Structure, Dynamics, Simulation
            * L3  327-02 Molecules, Materials, Surfaces
            * L3  307-01 Experimental Condensed Matter Physics
            * L3  307-02 Theoretical Condensed Matter Physics
            * L3  308-01 Optics, Quantum Optics, Atoms, Molecules, Plasmas
            * L3  309-01 Nuclear and Elementary Particle Physics, Quantum Mechanics, Relativity, Fields
            * L3  310-01 Statistical Physics, Soft Matter, Biological Physics, Nonlinear Dynamics
            * L3  311-01 Astrophysics and Astronomy
            * L3  312-01 Mathematics
            * L3  313-01 Atmospheric Science
            * L3  313-02 Oceanography
            * L3  314-01 Geology and Palaeontology
            * L3  315-01 Geophysics
            * L3  315-02 Geodesy, Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing, Geoinformatics, Cartography
            * L3  316-01 Mineralogy, Petrology and Geochemistry
            * L3  317-01 Physical Geography
            * L3  317-02 Human Geography
            * L3  318-01 Hydrogeology, Hydrology, Limnology, Urban Water Management, Water Chemistry, Integrated Water Resources Management 
            * L3  401-01 Metal-Cutting and Abrasive Manufacturing Engineering
            * L3  401-02 Primary Shaping and Reshaping Technology, Additive Manufacturing
            * L3  401-03 Joining and Separation Technology
            * L3  401-04 Plastics Engineering
            * L3  401-05 Production Systems, Operations Management, Quality Management and Factory Planning
            * L3  401-06 Production Automation
            * L3  402-01 Engineering Design, Machine Elements, Product Development
            * L3  402-02 Mechanics
            * L3  402-03 Lightweight Construction, Textile Technology
            * L3  402-04 Acoustics
            * L3  403-01 Chemical and Thermal Process Engineering
            * L3  403-02 Technical Chemistry
            * L3  403-03 Mechanical Process Engineering
            * L3  403-04 Biological Process Engineering
            * L3  404-01 Energy Process Engineering
            * L3  404-02 Technical Thermodynamics
            * L3  404-03 Fluid Mechanics
            * L3  404-04 Hydraulic and Turbo Engines and Piston Engines
            * L3  405-01 Metallurgical, Thermal and Thermomechanical Treatment of Materials
            * L3  405-02 Materials in Sintering Processes and Generative Manufacturing Processes
            * L3  405-03 Coating and Surface Technology
            * L3  405-04 Mechanical Properties of Metallic Materials and their Microstructural Origins
            * L3  405-05 Glass, Ceramics and Derived Composites
            * L3  405-06 Polymeric and Biogenic Materials and Derived Composites
            * L3  406-01 Synthesis and Properties of Functional Materials
            * L3  406-02 Biomaterials
            * L3  406-03 Thermodynamics and Kinetics as well as Properties of Phases and Microstructure of Materials
            * L3  406-04 Computer-Aided Design of Materials and Simulation of Materials Behaviour from Atomic to Microscopic Scale
            * L3  407-01 Automation, Control Systems, Robotics, Mechatronics, Cyber Physical Systems
            * L3  407-02 Measurement Systems
            * L3  407-03 Microsystems
            * L3  407-04 Traffic and Transport Systems, Logistics, Intelligent and Automated Traffic
            * L3  407-05 Human Factors, Ergonomics, Human-Machine Systems
            * L3  407-06 Biomedical Systems Technology
            * L3  408-01 Electronic Semiconductors, Components, Circuits, Systems
            * L3  408-02 Communications, High-Frequency and Network Technology, Theoretical Electrical Engineering
            * L3  408-03 Electrical Energy Generation, Distribution, Application
            * L3  409-01 Theoretical Computer Science
            * L3  409-02 Software Engineering and Programming Languages
            * L3  409-03 Security and Dependability
            * L3  409-04 Operating, Communication, Database and Distributed Systems
            * L3  409-05 Interactive and Intelligent Systems, Image and Language Processing, Computer Graphics and Visualisation
            * L3  409-06 Information Systems, Process and Knowledge Management
            * L3  409-07 Computer Architecture and Embedded Systems
            * L3  409-08 Massively Parallel and Data-Intensive Systems
            * L3  410-01 Architecture, Building and Construction History, Construction Research, Sustainable Building Technology
            * L3  410-02 Urbanism, Spatial Planning, Transportation and Infrastructure Planning, Landscape Planning
            * L3  410-03 Construction Material Sciences, Chemistry, Building Physics
            * L3  410-04 Structural Engineering, Building Informatics and Construction Operation
            * L3  410-05 Applied Mechanics, Statics and Dynamics
            * L3  410-06 Geotechnics, Hydraulic Engineering
nichtich commented 2 years ago

Thanks for spotting this - the rows are not properly ordered in the CSV. Will fix it tomorrow.

andrecastro0o commented 2 years ago

Thank you @nichtich That would be great.

nichtich commented 2 years ago

Fixed and re-imported to https://coli-conc.gbv.de/cocoda/app/. Also available at http://bartoc.org/en/node/520#content