search

gcv / julia-snail

An Emacs development environment for Julia
GNU General Public License v3.0
231 stars 21 forks source link

Issues using ob-julia #119

Closed fcdimitr closed 8 months ago

fcdimitr commented 1 year ago

Thank you very much for this great package!

I am using doom-emacs with minor customizations. I have installed julia-snail and am trying to use ob-julia in org.

The issue is that anytime I try to evaluate a code block, the org-babel-execute:julia function becomes redefined by the ob-julia packaged with org. I have yet to find a way to force to use the version that comes with this package. I am currently unable to run the ob-julia version that ships with this package.

Do you have any ideas or workarounds on how to resolve this issue?

This may not be an issue of julia-snail, but I am not sure where to post it.

Thanks!

gcv commented 1 year ago

It seems like it should be possible to patch this, either directly in Snail, or by coordinating with whoever maintains the code which overrides the Snail Babel integration.

@MasonProtter, what do you think?

aosidnf commented 1 year ago

maybe these patches for the doom repo are helpful for you? http://0x0.st/H8C6.patch http://0x0.st/H8C0.patch

RomeoV commented 9 months ago

I haven't been able to get it to work, even with the patches..

RomeoV commented 9 months ago

However, actually hlissner (the doom emacs creator) posted a simple fix here:

;;; add to $DOOMDIR/config.el
(add-to-list '+org-babel-mode-alist '(julia . julia-snail))

Using that, it seems to work :)

edmundmiller commented 8 months ago

He's the best!

gcv commented 8 months ago

I don't use Doom Emacs, so I don't fully follow what happened. Does this mean this ticket can be closed as solved?

RomeoV commented 8 months ago

I'm considering making a PR to the doomemacs repo to put it into the julia-snail config, but I'm actually surprised that you don't need it in Vanilla emacs. Would it make sense to include this line in this repo here directly?

gcv commented 8 months ago

Not as far as I can tell. Using Emacs 29.1 and its included Org 9.6.6, I don't see any sign of a org-babel-execute:julia function. I think + prefixes are a Doom thing, so +org-babel-mode-alist should not be added to a non-Doom codebase. I also don't see anything resembling org-babel-mode-alist in my Emacs environment. The ob-julia Snail extension works fine for me without any of these changes. 🤷

RomeoV commented 8 months ago

Then you can close this issue imo. Thanks!