geneontology / go-annotation

This repository hosts the tracker for issues pertaining to GO annotations.
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
34 stars 10 forks source link

human glycosylation annotations over-inflated #1865

Closed ValWood closed 4 years ago

ValWood commented 6 years ago

A lot of these appear to be "glycosylated" not involved in glycosylation

first one I looked at: a cholesterol transporter https://www.uniprot.org/uniprot/O15118 IDA https://www.uniprot.org/citations/10821832

ValWood commented 6 years ago

https://www.uniprot.org/uniprot/P07306 TAS via reactome (receptor for exocytosed glycoprotein) https://www.uniprot.org/uniprot/P07911 TAS via reactome

P98088 MUC5A_HUMAN Mucin-5AC O-glycan processing Source: Reactome Q02505 MUC3A_HUMAN Mucin-3A O-glycan processing Source: Reactome Q02817 MUC2_HUMAN Mucin-2 O-glycan processing Source: Reactome Q5SSG8 MUC21_HUMAN Mucin-21 O-glycan processing Source: Reactome Q8N307 MUC20_HUMAN Mucin-20 Q8N387 MUC15_HUMAN Mucin-15 Q8TAX7 MUC7_HUMAN Mucin-7 Q8WXI7 MUC16_HUMAN Mucin-16 Q96DR8 MUCL1_HUMAN Mucin-like protein 1 Q99102 MUC4_HUMAN Mucin-4 Q9HC84 MUC5B_HUMAN Mucin-5B Q9UKN1 MUC12_HUMAN Mucin-12 Q9H195 MUC3B_HUMAN Mucin-3B Q9H3R2 MUC13_HUMAN Mucin-13 Q685J3 MUC17_HUMAN Mucin-17 Q6W4X9 MUC6_HUMAN Mucin-6 Q7Z5P9 MUC19_HUMAN Mucin-19 P27918 PROP_HUMAN Properdin protein O-linked fucosylation Source: Reactome

deustp01 commented 6 years ago

Those TAS from us should go away with our next release at the end of the month.

ValWood commented 6 years ago

Brilliant. I'll close this one. I noticed some others which might be slightly different reasons. so I will open tickets for these later......But am I OK to assume that any resulting in "target of process annotated to process" are fixed for all processes?

v

deustp01 commented 6 years ago

"OK to assume that any resulting in "target of process annotated to process" are fixed for all processes?"

The discrepancy arises at the level of individual reactions (molecular functions) and propagates to the pathways (processes) that those reactions are parts of. Where the reaction involves catalytic activity (GO:0003824) and its children or transporter activity (GO:0005215) and its children, the discrepancies should be fixed. In the cases of proteins and complexes traversing the nuclear pore or proteins associated with intraqcellular vesicles moving to the cell membrane and extracellular space, the fixes will take longer.

ValWood commented 6 years ago

reopening as there are non -reatcome ones above.

ValWood commented 6 years ago

From MGI @ukemi @hdrabkin please assign appropriate person

ISS from mouse http://www.uniprot.org/citations/24795147 Seems to be a phenotype due to Golgi disruption rather than an role in glycosylation

ValWood commented 6 years ago

UniProt @ggeorghiou

ukemi commented 6 years ago

@vanaukenk and @pgaudet This is a nice edge case for the new qualifiers and might be worth discussing on a call. You need a good Golgi apparatus to get proper glycosylation, but if we make the cut off of the glycosylation being the enzymatic steps, then the organization of the Golgi would be upstream of it. In my opinion it is still very important to capture this kind of information in some way. The last case is even more interesting. The complex between the beta subunit and the alpha subunit is required for the alpha subunit to be glycosylated. The beta is annotated to positive regulation, but if we make the cut off being the enzymatic steps, it would act upstream as well.

ggeorghiou commented 4 years ago

All of these annotations have been deleted or updated accordingly. Closing this ticket.