[some stuff, e.g. MetaCyc dbxrefs & synonyms, not shown]
These terms were apparently added for the sake of consistency with EC, but they do not conform to GO function term criteria. The parent (16821) and several of the children incorporate process information in the term strings. Other children look like gene products, and some of them also have process information in the definitions.
Note that we can keep these children of GO:0016821, because they were improved as part of SF 800360:
%plus-end-directed microtubule motor activity ; GO:0008574 ; EC:3.6.4.4
%minus-end-directed microtubule motor activity ; GO:0008569 ; EC:3.6.4.5
and this one seems to be OK as is:
%microtubule-severing ATPase activity ; GO:0008568 ; EC:3.6.4.3
The above can go under ATPase activity ; GO:0016887 or one of its children.
Specifics:
%hydrolase activity\, acting on acid anhydrides\, involved in cellular and subcellular movement ; G\
O:0016821 ; EC:3.6.4.-
reason: includes process information
reannotate to: hydrolase activity, acting on acid anhydrides
reason: represents a gene product; definition includes process information
reannotate to: ATPase activity ; GO:0016887
%dynein ATPase activity ; GO:0008567 ; EC:3.6.4.2
reason: represents a gene product; definition includes process information
reannotate to: microtubule motor activity ; GO:0003777 or child, microtubule-based movement ; GO:0007018 or child
also make 'dynein' a narrower-than synonym of GO:0003777
%myosin ATPase activity ; GO:0008570 ; EC:3.6.4.1
reason: represents a gene product; definition includes process information
reannotate to: microfilament motor activity ; GO:0000146, actin filament-based movement ; GO:0030048 or child
As noted on the mailing list, I propose to make some molecular function terms obsolete:
%hydrolase activity, acting on acid anhydrides, involved in cellular and subcellular movement ; GO:0016821 %chaperonin ATPase activity ; GO:0003763 ; EC:3.6.4.9 %dynein ATPase activity ; GO:0008567 ; EC:3.6.4.2 %myosin ATPase activity ; GO:0008570 ; EC:3.6.4.1 %non-chaperonin molecular chaperone ATPase activity ; GO:0008571 ; EC:3.6.4.10 %nucleoplasmin ATPase activity ; GO:0008572 ; EC:3.6.4.11 %peroxisome-assembly ATPase activity ; GO:0008573 ; EC:3.6.4.7 %vesicle-fusing ATPase activity ; GO:0008576 ; EC:3.6.4.6
[some stuff, e.g. MetaCyc dbxrefs & synonyms, not shown]
These terms were apparently added for the sake of consistency with EC, but they do not conform to GO function term criteria. The parent (16821) and several of the children incorporate process information in the term strings. Other children look like gene products, and some of them also have process information in the definitions.
Note that we can keep these children of GO:0016821, because they were improved as part of SF 800360: %plus-end-directed microtubule motor activity ; GO:0008574 ; EC:3.6.4.4 %minus-end-directed microtubule motor activity ; GO:0008569 ; EC:3.6.4.5
and this one seems to be OK as is: %microtubule-severing ATPase activity ; GO:0008568 ; EC:3.6.4.3
The above can go under ATPase activity ; GO:0016887 or one of its children.
Specifics:
%hydrolase activity\, acting on acid anhydrides\, involved in cellular and subcellular movement ; G\ O:0016821 ; EC:3.6.4.-
%chaperonin ATPase activity ; GO:0003763 ; EC:3.6.4.9
%dynein ATPase activity ; GO:0008567 ; EC:3.6.4.2
%myosin ATPase activity ; GO:0008570 ; EC:3.6.4.1
%non-chaperonin molecular chaperone ATPase activity ; GO:0008571 ; EC:3.6.4.10
%nucleoplasmin ATPase activity ; GO:0008572 ; EC:3.6.4.11
%peroxisome-assembly ATPase activity ; GO:0008573 ; EC:3.6.4.7
%vesicle-fusing ATPase activity ; GO:0008576 ; EC:3.6.4.6
Reported by: mah11
Original Ticket: "geneontology/ontology-requests/1332":https://sourceforge.net/p/geneontology/ontology-requests/1332