geneontology / go-ontology

Source ontology files for the Gene Ontology
http://geneontology.org/page/download-ontology
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
220 stars 40 forks source link

NTR: different RNA capping mechanism, decapping #17383

Closed keseler closed 5 years ago

keseler commented 5 years ago

In addition to the well-known RNA capping of eukaryotic pol II transcripts, it turns out that different cap modifications on RNA (NAD, dephospho-CoA) also exist in prokaryotes. However, the mechanism for incorporation of the cap modification is different; here, they are incorporated as "non-canonical initiating nucleotides" at transcription initiation (PMID 27383794, 29681497). This is in fact not specific to prokaryotes; it also happens in yeast, PMID 27383794.

To me, the existing "RNA capping" term GO:0036260 definitely sounds broad enough to accommodate this process, but its definition would currently be too specific. The specific cap structures described above could be added as child terms to GO:0036260.

Decapping of NAD-modified RNAs should also get a GO term (as a MF, because it is only one step?); it's a hydrolase, NadC in E. coli (PMID 25533955, 27428510).

Cheers, Ingrid

vanaukenk commented 5 years ago

@keseler

I agree that the current definition of 'RNA capping' GO:0036260 should now be made more general to accommodate other mechanisms of RNA capping and other species.

For the more specific child terms for NAD and dephospho-CoA capping, what bacterial gene products would you annotate? RNAP subunits? Can you suggest definitions for these terms?

For RNA decapping, we do currently have BP terms for decapping (e.g. deadenylation-dependent decapping of nuclear-transcribed mRNA GO:0000290) but I'd like to confirm with the GO editors on whether an enzyme like the NudC hydrolase should just get an MF annotation for this or also a BP decapping annotation. A BP annotation to some type of RNA processing term seems warranted.

Side note: NudC is a nice example of a homodimeric emergent function. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5003112/

sylvainpoux commented 5 years ago

Hi, apparently both Ingrid @keseler and me requested GO terms for the same pathway. For information, the addition of NAD-cap is not so clear in eukaryotes, and it looks like that at least some NAD-cap is added post-transcriptionally, since a number of snoRNAs that are produced post-transcriptionally have a NAD-cap (PMID:28283058)

Please also note that there are 2 different mechanisms for NAP-decapping in eukaryotes, with two different reactions, one forming NMN and one forming NAD (PMID:28283058, PMID:31101919)

vanaukenk commented 5 years ago

Closing this ticket, as the remaining work has been done in #17594, save adding Rhea xrefs when they become public. @keseler - I think we've added most of what can be added at this point, but please let me know if you have any additional questions/comments. Thx.